Cabbage Root Maggot
The cabbage root maggot (Delia radicum) is the larva of a small gray fly that lays its eggs in the soil at the base of cabbage-family plants. The maggots eat the roots. Young transplants wilt and die, and radishes, turnips and rutabagas are left tunneled and inedible.
No spray available to home gardeners kills the maggots once they are in the roots, so every control is prevention. The two that work best are a row cover or insect netting put on at planting, on ground that grew no cabbage-family crop the year before, and planting after the first flight of flies is over.
Identification
- Fly: gray, bristly and built like a housefly but about half as long (roughly 1/4 inch), with dark stripes on the thorax. It cannot be told from the onion maggot and seedcorn maggot flies by eye; the crop it is hovering around is the clue.
- Eggs: tiny, white and bullet-shaped, laid in the soil against the stem and in nearby cracks. A female lays about 50 to 200. Brush soil away from a few stems to look; commercial growers expect real damage at an average of one egg per stem.
- Maggots: white, legless and tapered toward the head, 1/4 to 1/3 inch long when full grown, on and inside the roots.
Damage
Transplants and seedlings. Plants wilt on sunny days, the outer leaves turn yellow or purplish, growth stalls and the plant may collapse. Pull one up and you find the roots chewed off or scarred with brown tunnels, often with maggots still in them. The wounds also let in rots such as blackleg and bacterial soft rot. Older plants with a big root system usually carry on.
Root crops. In radishes, turnips and rutabagas the maggots tunnel through the part you eat, so even light feeding ruins the crop. Every generation does this, including the late-summer one.
A cabbage-family plant that wilts on sunny days and has swollen, knotted roots instead of tunneled ones has clubroot, a soil disease with a different set of answers.
Life cycle and when the flies arrive
The insect spends the winter as a pupa in the top few inches of soil where cabbage-family crops grew. Flies emerge in spring and can travel up to a mile to find hosts. Eggs hatch in two to seven days, the maggots feed for three to four weeks, then pupate in the soil. Wisconsin sees two or three generations a year and central New England three to four.
The first flight is the one that kills transplants. Extension services time it three ways:
- By indicator plants. Flies start laying about when yellow rocket (wintercress, Barbarea vulgaris), the yellow-flowered mustard of roadsides and field edges, comes into bloom. Wisconsin adds forsythia in bloom.
- By the calendar. Around mid-May in New England and Wisconsin.
- By degree days. Wisconsin and Minnesota count from ground thaw with a 43°F base: the first three generations peak at about 300, 1,475 and 2,650 degree days. UMass counts from January 1 with a 40°F base and gets 452, 1,261, 2,176 and 3,014. Use the model your own state's extension service publishes.
A flight in late August to early September is the one that damages fall radishes, turnips and rutabagas.
Why cool, wet springs are the worst. The eggs survive best in cool, moist soil. When the top two to three inches of soil stay above 95°F for several days, the eggs die, and that normally happens by late May or early June. A rainy spring keeps the soil cool and the eggs alive. The flies are also drawn to freshly tilled soil with decaying organic matter in it: a cover crop just turned under, green manure or fresh animal manure. Finish working those in three to four weeks before you plant. See using manure in the vegetable garden.
What works
Cover the crop at planting, on rotated ground. A lightweight row cover or insect netting keeps the flies from reaching the soil around the stems. Standard mesh of about 1.3 to 1.4 mm is fine enough for root flies. Put it on the day you sow or transplant and bury the edges in soil. The condition that decides whether this works: do not cover ground where cabbage-family crops, or mustard cover crops, grew last year. The pupae are already in that soil and the flies will emerge under the cover. Minnesota advises having covers in place by early to mid-May and keeping them on until the end of the month; UMass says to leave them until the first flight is over, the soil has warmed and the plants are large. Root crops, fall sowings included, are safest covered from sowing to harvest. Details are on the row covers and insect netting page.
Plant after the first flight. Minnesota suggests waiting until June 1 where you can. UMass calls late May into June generally safer, and Wisconsin finds that plantings made after mid-June suffer less than earlier ones. The cost is that cabbage-family crops want cool weather, so check your frost dates (by zip code) to see how much room you have.
Rotate, and clear out old roots. In a small garden rotation will not keep the flies away, because they fly in from up to a mile off. What it does is make covers work. After harvest, pull the stumps and roots of cabbage-family crops and destroy them, or till the residue under, and pull wild mustards, which are hosts too.
Help plants outgrow the damage. Plant into soil above 50°F, keep plants watered, and pull soil up around the stems so they can root above the injury.
Stem collars for transplants. A flat disc of roofing felt, carpet underlay or cardboard, 3 to 6 inches across, slit to the center and fitted snugly around the stem at soil level, stops the fly laying against the stem; eggs laid on the disc tend to dry out. The Royal Horticultural Society and University of Maine Extension both describe the method, but none of the extension sources used here gives a figure for how much damage collars prevent, and the Massachusetts, Wisconsin and Minnesota pages do not mention them. Treat collars as a reasonable extra for a few transplants; they do nothing for radishes or turnips sown in rows.
Protect the predators. Ground beetles and rove beetles eat the eggs, maggots and pupae and, according to UMass, can kill a high proportion of them. One rove beetle, Aleochara bilineata, is a parasite of the maggots as well as a predator. Broadcast soil insecticides kill these beetles.
Beneficial nematodes. Steinernema feltiae attacks the maggots and stays active in soil as cool as 50°F. UMass gives a rate of 100,000 to 125,000 nematodes per transplant, drenched around the plant, in soil kept moist. See buying beneficial insects for how to handle them.
What is unproven or does not help
- Wood ash and diatomaceous earth around the stems. University of Maine says a layer of either "can also be helpful" at deterring egg laying, and Wisconsin lists diatomaceous earth as something that may help. Neither gives trial results, and diatomaceous earth stops working when it is damp, which is the weather this pest likes. Do not rely on them.
- Strong-smelling companion plants. The trial evidence on companion plants and the cabbage root fly is set out on the green cabbage page.
- Spraying after you see wilting. University of Minnesota Extension is blunt: no insecticide is available to home gardeners as a pre-plant treatment, and "once you notice damage from root maggots it's too late to treat them." Farms use soil drenches at planting; nothing works once the maggots are feeding.
Onion maggot and seedcorn maggot
Two close relatives look the same as flies and are handled the same way.
Onion maggot (Delia antiqua) attacks onions, garlic and leeks. The maggots eat the roots and bore into the bulb, and soft rots follow. Its first flight begins about when the cabbage maggot's is peaking. Rotate, cover at planting only where no onion-family crop grew last year, and do not leave cull onions lying in the garden. See growing onions.
Seedcorn maggot (Delia platura) eats germinating seeds and seedlings of beans, peas, corn, cucumbers, squash and many others, so rows come up patchy or not at all. It flies earliest of the three and is worst in cool, wet soil with fresh organic matter in it: a cover crop just turned under, manure, unfinished compost or seed-meal fertilizers. Work those in at least four weeks before sowing, and wait to sow until the soil is warm enough for seeds to come up fast. If a sowing fails, UMass advises waiting at least five days to replant if the maggots are 1/4 inch long, and ten days if they are smaller. A row cover helps only if the flies are arriving from elsewhere, not when they are emerging from the bed itself.
For other problems of these crops, see the cabbage family overview and flea beetles.
Sources
- Cabbage Root Maggot, UMass Extension Vegetable Program
- Root maggots, University of Minnesota Extension
- Cabbage Maggot, University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension
- Cabbage root fly, Royal Horticultural Society
- Cabbage Maggots (Fact Sheet 5005), University of Maine Cooperative Extension
- Seedcorn Maggot and Onion Maggot, UMass Extension Vegetable Program