Why Do My Tomatoes Grow Deformed?

Two badly misshapen tomatoes with lobes and corky catfacing scars

Most misshapen tomatoes are perfectly good to eat once you cut away the scarred or cracked parts. Only fruit with mold or soft rot should go on the compost pile. Many deformities start in the flower bud, weeks before you see the fruit, which is why they are easier to prevent next season than to fix this one.

Catfacing

Catfaced fruit has a puckered, lumpy blossom end with brown, corky scars and sometimes deep cavities, as in the photo above. It begins when the flower develops abnormally. The usual trigger is cool weather, especially nights in the 50s °F or colder, while the flower buds are forming a few weeks before bloom, so the first fruits of the season are the most affected. Herbicide drift (lawn weed killers such as 2,4-D), heavy pruning and too much nitrogen can also cause it.

Large-fruited beefsteaks and heirlooms are by far the most prone. Their first flower is often a "megabloom," several flowers fused into one, and it produces the strangest fruit of all; some gardeners pinch it off.

Prevention:

  • Don't rush transplanting. Wait until nights stay above 50°F, or protect early plants with row covers or water-filled plant protectors.
  • Keep lawn and weed herbicides away from tomatoes, including spray drift on windy days.
  • If catfacing ruins your crop every year, grow smooth-fruited slicers or paste types instead of big heirlooms.

Zippering

A zippered tomato has a thin brown scar running from the stem end down the side of the fruit, crossed by short lines like the teeth of a zipper, and sometimes an open hole. It happens when part of the flower (the anthers) sticks to the tiny developing fruit and leaves a scar as the fruit swells. It is more common in cool weather and in certain varieties. The fruit is fine to eat. If one variety zippers badly every year, try another.

Cracking

Cracks either radiate out from the stem (radial cracking) or circle it (concentric cracking). Both happen when the fruit takes up water faster than the skin can stretch, usually after heavy rain or a big watering follows a dry spell, and more often in hot weather and on fruit exposed to direct sun.

Prevention:

  • Keep soil moisture even with regular deep watering and a 2–3 inch mulch.
  • Don't strip leaves; foliage shading the fruit reduces cracking.
  • Pick fruit at the first blush of color before heavy rain and let it ripen indoors (when to pick tomatoes).
  • Look for varieties described as crack-resistant.

Puffiness

Puffy tomatoes feel light for their size and look boxy or angular. Cut one open and you'll find empty gaps between the outer wall and the seeds. Puffiness comes from poor pollination or poor seed development, brought on by heat, cold or cloudy weather during bloom, or by too much nitrogen. In greenhouses and sheltered spots, vibrating the flowers helps (hand pollinating tomatoes).

Insect and virus damage

  • Stink bugs and leaf-footed bugs pierce the fruit to feed. Each puncture leaves a cloudy, whitish or yellow patch under the skin with hard, spongy tissue beneath, and fruit fed on while small can end up dimpled and distorted. Hand-pick the bugs into soapy water early in the morning when they are sluggish, and keep weeds down around the garden.
  • Viruses such as tomato spotted wilt cause small, misshapen fruit with rings or blotchy color. Infected plants won't recover; pull them. See common tomato diseases.

Nutrient imbalances

Heavy nitrogen feeding makes catfacing and puffiness worse. A shortage of potassium shows up as blotchy, uneven ripening and hard yellow shoulders rather than odd shapes (see why tomatoes stay green). A soil test and a moderate feeding program prevent both.

Variety

Some tomatoes simply grow lumpy. Old beefsteak heirlooms such as Brandywine are naturally ribbed, lobed and prone to catfacing and cracking, while modern hybrid slicers were bred for smooth, uniform fruit. If looks matter, grow hybrids; if flavor matters more, accept some odd shapes.