Row Covers and Insect Netting: Mesh Sizes and Timing

A cover over the crop is the most dependable way to keep insects off vegetables without spraying, provided three things are right: it goes on at planting, before the pest arrives; every edge is sealed to the ground; and the bed did not grow the same crop family last year. A cover only keeps out pests that come from outside. Pests that spent the winter in the soil of that bed come up underneath it.

There are two materials. Fabric row cover also holds warmth, which is useful in spring and fall and a problem in summer. Insect netting stays cool but gives no frost protection.

Fabric row cover

Row cover (also sold as frost cloth, garden fleece or by brand names such as Agribon and Reemay) is a thin spunbonded polypropylene or polyester fabric. Rain and air pass through it. It is sold by weight:

Weight Ounces per square yard Light let through Frost protection Use
Lightweight about 0.45 90 to 95% about 2°F Insect barrier; can stay on greens, beets and beans from sowing to harvest
Medium 0.5 to 1.0 70 to 85% 4 to 6°F Spring and fall crops, insect and frost protection together
Heavy 1.5 to 2.2 30 to 50% up to 8°F Frost and freeze protection and overwintering crops

The figures are University of Maryland Extension's. Utah State puts it as protection down to about 28°F for medium weights and 24 to 28°F for heavy ones. Fabric lasts one to three seasons, the lightest grades the shortest.

Insect netting

Insect netting is a woven or knitted polyethylene mesh. It lets through about 80 percent of light, adds little warmth, lasts five to ten years, and is the better choice from late spring to early fall. What it stops depends on the size of the holes. The Royal Horticultural Society's guide:

Mesh opening Keeps out Not reliable against
Butterfly netting, 4 to 7 mm Cabbage white butterflies (only if leaves do not touch it), birds Everything smaller
Standard, 1.3 to 1.4 mm Butterflies and moths, cabbage root maggot fly, onion maggot fly, carrot rust fly, seedcorn maggot fly Aphids, flea beetles
Fine, 0.8 mm The above plus flea beetles, leaf miner flies, aphids and whiteflies Thrips
Ultrafine, 0.3 to 0.6 mm The above plus thrips

Sources do not fully agree on the small pests. Utah State Extension's table lists aphids, flea beetles, whiteflies, thrips and spider mites as excluded only by its finest grade, 0.35 mm. If flea beetles or aphids are the target, buy 0.8 mm or finer. Finer mesh holds more heat and humidity. Stretching netting tight over hoops opens the holes, so leave it a little slack.

Heat under covers

In summer the air under fabric row cover can be 5 to 15°F hotter than outside. Tomato, pepper and bean flowers drop when it goes above about 90°F, and cool-season crops suffer. Take fabric off cool-season crops by about mid-June, or switch to netting, which is much more open and warms the crop very little.

Putting a cover on so it works

  • Cover the day you sow or transplant, and check transplants for eggs and insects first. A cover put on late traps the pest inside, away from its predators.
  • Use hoops for anything taller than salad greens. Lightweight fabric can lie directly on low crops with plenty of slack. Hoops keep heavier fabric and all netting off the leaves; where a cover touches a leaf, moths and butterflies can lay eggs through it and wind rubs the plants. Hoops of 9-gauge wire cut into 7-foot lengths, or 1/2-inch PVC pipe slid over short stakes of rebar, set 2 to 4 feet apart, make a tunnel about 2 feet high.
  • Seal every edge. Bury the edges under 2 inches of soil, or weigh them down along their whole length with boards, sandbags or pipe. Pins alone leave gaps and tear fabric. Mend holes with tape.

Never over last year's ground

Do not cover a bed where the same crop family grew the year before. These pests overwinter in or on the soil and emerge under the cover:

  • Flea beetles (cabbage family, eggplant and potatoes): see flea beetles.
  • Root maggots: cabbage maggot pupae where brassicas grew, onion maggot pupae where onions grew. See cabbage root maggot.
  • Squash vine borer, which winters as a cocoon in the soil where squash grew: see squash vine borer.
  • Colorado potato beetle, where potatoes grew.

Seedcorn maggots also emerge from a bed where a cover crop or manure has just been turned in.

When to cover and uncover, by crop

Crop Mainly keeps out Cover on Cover off
Cabbage, broccoli, kale, collards, Brussels sprouts Cabbage caterpillars, flea beetles, root maggot flies, aphids At transplanting At harvest. No pollination needed.
Radishes, turnips, arugula, Asian greens Flea beetles, root maggot flies At sowing At harvest
Lettuce, spinach, chard, beets Leaf miner flies, aphids, leafhoppers, rabbits At sowing At harvest
Carrots Leafhoppers that carry aster yellows, carrot rust fly At sowing At harvest
Onions, leeks, garlic Onion maggot fly (thrips only with ultrafine mesh) At planting At harvest, or once plants are large and the first flight is over
Potatoes Colorado potato beetle, flea beetles, leafhoppers At planting Can stay on; lift to hill
Bush beans Mexican bean beetle At sowing Can stay on to harvest
Tomatoes, peppers, eggplant Flea beetles, Colorado potato beetle, aphids At transplanting When they start to flower
Squash, pumpkins, melons, cucumbers Cucumber beetles, squash bugs, squash vine borer At sowing or transplanting When the first female flowers open

Squash, pumpkins, melons and most cucumbers depend completely on insects for pollination, so the cover has to come off once female flowers (the ones with a tiny fruit behind the petals) appear. The alternative is to keep the cover on and hand-pollinate. Parthenocarpic cucumbers, which include many English and Persian types, set fruit without pollination and can stay covered all season. Tomatoes, peppers and eggplant pollinate themselves but need air movement to shake the pollen loose, and they overheat under fabric, so uncover them at flowering too.

By the time a cover comes off, the plants are past the seedling stage, when cucumber beetles and flea beetles do the most harm. Start checking squash for squash bug eggs as soon as it is uncovered.

Looking after a covered crop

Weeds grow faster under a cover than outside it. Lift one side every two to three weeks to weed and thin, then seal it again; a mulch laid before covering saves work. Rain goes through both fabric and netting, though heavy fabric sheds some; drip lines underneath are easier than lifting the cover to water.

Look for trouble while you are in there. Aphids, spider mites and whiteflies that get inside multiply fast because their predators are shut out, and the humid air suits slugs (slugs and snails) and leaf diseases. If a pest has built up, take the cover off and let the predators in.

Frost protection and season extension

Depending on weight, row cover keeps a crop 2 to 8°F warmer on a frosty night and brings spring harvests forward by a week or two. Use medium or heavy fabric on hoops, with the edges held down so the ground's warmth stays in, and take heavy fabric off or vent it on warm days: it can raise the daytime temperature by 10°F or more. Netting gives no meaningful frost protection. Look up your frost dates by zip code.

Remove covers for good on a cloudy day, or in stages, so plants raised in shelter harden off. Store fabric dry, out of the sun and in a closed container; sunlight breaks it down and mice shred it.

Bird netting and wildlife

The wide black plastic mesh sold as bird netting is not insect netting, and it is a hazard. Loosely draped or left lying on the ground, it entangles and kills songbirds and snakes. Fine insect mesh, with its edges secured, is one of the safer coverings. If you need bird netting over berries, stretch it taut over a frame, bury or pin every edge, check it daily and take it down after harvest. Stiff wire such as chicken wire is safer where it will do. More in why netting quality matters and protecting greens from leaf-eating pests.

Sources