Mulching the Garden: Wood Chips, Straw, Leaves and What the Research Says

Mulch is anything laid on top of the soil and left there, not dug in. The short version: use coarse arborist wood chips, about 4 inches deep, around trees, shrubs and perennials and on paths; use straw, shredded leaves or dried grass clippings in annual vegetable beds, and put them down after the soil has warmed; keep every mulch back from stems and trunks; and know where hay, straw and clippings came from, because some carry weed-killers.

Much of what gardeners hear about mulch is not borne out by trials. Wood chips on the surface do not rob established plants of nitrogen, do not acidify soil and do not attract termites. Landscape fabric is not permanent weed control. The evidence on cardboard is mixed, and this page says where.

What mulch does

  • Saves water. Mulch cuts evaporation from the soil surface. Colorado State University Extension puts the saving in a vegetable garden at around half the irrigation.
  • Evens out soil temperature. Organic mulches keep soil cooler in summer and warmer in winter. Black plastic warms it.
  • Suppresses weeds by blocking light, if it is deep enough. A thin layer feeds and waters the weeds along with everything else.
  • Stops erosion, crusting and compaction from rain and feet.
  • Keeps soil off the plants. A mulch is a barrier against the soil-borne organisms that rain splashes onto the leaves and fruit of tomatoes, squash and cucumbers; see tomato diseases.
  • Feeds the soil. Organic mulches add organic matter and a slow trickle of nutrients as they decay.
  • Steadies moisture, which reduces blossom end rot.

Materials compared

Extension guides do not agree exactly on depth; where they differ, both figures are given.

Material Depth Best use Watch for
Arborist wood chips 4 to 6 inches; no more than 4 close to trees Trees, shrubs, perennials, paths Not for annual vegetable rows
Bark, shredded or nuggets 2 to 3 inches; 1 to 2 if finely shredded Ornamental beds Fine bark packs down; nuggets float away
Straw 3 to 4 inches; up to 6 to 8 of loose straw Vegetable beds, potatoes Stray grain seedlings; herbicide residue
Hay As straw Only if weed-free and unsprayed Weed seeds; herbicide residue
Shredded leaves 2 to 4 inches Vegetable and flower beds Whole leaves mat; shred them first
Grass clippings Thin layers; 2 to 3 inches at most once dry Vegetable rows Fresh clippings mat and smell; treated lawns
Compost 1 to 2 inches Vegetable and flower beds Counts toward the year's compost; adds phosphorus
Pine needles 2 to 4 inches Shrubs, slopes, paths None; they do not acidify soil
Black plastic One sheet Tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, melons, squash Needs drip line under it; remove each fall
Red plastic One sheet Tomatoes Benefit reported only in cloudy climates
Landscape fabric One layer Under gravel paths; annual crops Weeds root into it; see below
Cardboard, newspaper One layer under other mulch Starting or renewing annual beds Sheds water when dry; shelters voles
Stone, gravel About 1 inch Paths, foundation strips Adds nothing to soil; reflects heat
Rubber Not recommended Burns readily; leaches zinc and other contaminants

Which mulch where

Around trees, shrubs and perennials, and on paths: arborist wood chips. These are the mixed chips of wood, bark and leaves that tree crews produce, often free for the asking. Because the pieces vary in size they don't pack down the way sawdust or fine bark does, and in comparisons of organic mulches they have been among the best at holding moisture, moderating temperature and stopping weeds. Washington State University recommends keeping them 4 to 6 inches deep for weed control. Penn State's advice for landscape trees is 2 to 4 inches and never more than 4, less on poorly drained soil. About 4 inches satisfies both.

In annual vegetable beds: straw, shredded leaves, dried grass clippings or compost. They break down within a season, are easy to pull aside for planting, and can be turned under in fall. Wood chips don't belong in the rows: they are slow to rot, get in the way of preparing a seedbed, and the thin nitrogen-poor zone where chips meet soil is exactly where seeds and shallow-rooted annuals grow. On the paths between beds, 3 to 4 inches of chips are ideal. For straw versus hay, see hay vs straw mulching.

For heat-loving crops in a short season: black plastic. Laid over moist soil one to three weeks before planting, with a soaker hose or drip line underneath, it warms the soil and stops weeds. Colorado State reports harvests two to three weeks earlier along the Front Range. It has to come up every fall. Clear plastic warms soil more but lets weeds grow under it. Red plastic is reported to raise tomato yields in cloudy climates; in Colorado's bright light the gain is insignificant.

The nitrogen question

The belief is that wood chips "rob" nitrogen. What research shows is narrower:

  • On the surface, the tie-up is confined to the boundary where mulch meets soil. Studies of woody mulches have found that over time they raise nutrient levels in the soil and in the leaves of the plants growing there, not lower them. Roots of established plants are below the boundary. The nitrogen-poor layer probably helps by starving weed seedlings.
  • Seedlings and shallow-rooted annuals live in that boundary, which is the reason to keep chips out of vegetable rows.
  • Dug in, woody material does tie up nitrogen. Sawdust, shavings and chips mixed into soil have far more carbon than nitrogen, and the microbes that rot them take nitrogen from the soil until they finish. Keep wood on top.

Some older extension sheets still say every organic mulch needs added nitrogen. If plants under fresh straw or leaves turn pale, a light side-dressing of nitrogen fixes it.

Acidity, termites and disease

  • Acidity. There is no evidence that wood chips or bark acidify the soil under them. The pH may shift within the rotting mulch itself, but changing the soil below takes chemistry, not mulch. The same is true of pine needles; see soil pH.
  • Termites. In University of Maryland tests, termites fed only eucalyptus, hardwood or pine bark mulch survived worse than those fed plain wood. In the field they were found just as often under pea gravel and bare soil as under bark mulches, and their activity was highest under gravel. What draws them is moisture, not the mulch as food. Any mulch can still give termites a covered bridge over treated soil, so keep a bare strip 6 to 12 inches wide along the foundation and never let mulch touch siding. Termites prefer cardboard to wood chips.
  • Disease from chipped trees. Most studies indicate that chips from diseased trees do not pass the disease to the roots of healthy trees when the chips are used on the surface. The fungi that grow in chips are decomposers. The risk is in digging such chips into the soil or using them as backfill, which nobody should do anyway.

Landscape fabric and sheet mulching

Landscape fabric works under a gravel path and in annual crop rows where it is lifted each year. In permanent beds it fails in a predictable way. Exposed to sun it can degrade within a year. Covered with mulch, the mulch turns to soil on top of it, weeds root into and through it, and the roots of your shrubs grow into it and tear when it is pulled out. Organic mulch, topped up as it settles, does the job better. The one place fabric earns its keep in a food garden is as the barrier under a raised bed built over contaminated soil; see lead in garden soil.

Cardboard and newspaper under another mulch work well in annual beds that are dug and watered regularly, and for smothering sod to start a bed. In permanent plantings they have drawbacks: wet layers pack into a sheet that slows water and air, dry cardboard sheds water, voles nest under it, and termites like it.

How much sheet mulch restricts air is debated. A 2019 greenhouse study measured how fast carbon dioxide passes through wood chips, cardboard, landscape fabric and plastic film. The rates differed by orders of magnitude, with wood chips the most open and plastic the least. Yet oxygen and carbon dioxide levels in the soil under cardboard and fabric were not significantly different from bare soil; only plastic changed them. So the study shows cardboard is a much tighter cover than chips, but not that it suffocates soil. A sensible reading is to use cardboard once, to clear ground, and not as a permanent layer renewed every year.

When to mulch

  • Warm-season vegetables: wait until the soil has warmed and the plants are growing. Straw or leaves put down early keep the soil cold, slow growth and delay the harvest.
  • Cool-season vegetables: any time.
  • Trees, shrubs and perennials: right after planting, and in spring before weed seeds germinate. Bare soil should not stay bare.
  • Always weed and water first. Mulch keeps moist soil moist and dry soil dry.

Mulch volcanoes

Mulch heaped against a tree trunk keeps the bark wet. Wet bark decays and lets in disease, voles gnaw it unseen under the cover and can girdle a young tree, and a thick, soggy pile starves roots of oxygen. Spread mulch wide and flat instead, out to the drip line if you can, and pull it back so the flare at the base of the trunk shows: 3 to 5 inches from a young tree, 8 to 10 inches from a mature one. Around vegetables, perennials and shrubs, leave 2 to 3 inches clear around the stems.

Herbicide residues in hay, straw and clippings

Hay and straw from fields sprayed with aminopyralid, clopyralid or picloram stay toxic to tomatoes, beans, peas, potatoes and lettuce for years, even after dry storage, and so do grass clippings from commercially treated turf. Don't mulch with clippings from a lawn treated with any weed-killer in the past month, and ask what was sprayed before you buy hay or straw. Hay vs straw mulching explains the bean test for a new source, and herbicide damage in the garden shows the symptoms.

Slugs and voles

Mulch shelters slugs and gives them a place to lay eggs, and wet, shaded soil under a heavy layer of chopped leaves suits them well. In a wet spring, rake out extra leaves and pull mulch back from seedlings; see slugs and snails. Voles nest under deep mulch and sheet mulch and feed on bark, which is the practical reason for the depth limits and for keeping mulch off trunks.

Sources