Using Manure in the Vegetable Garden

Manure adds organic matter and a modest, slow supply of nutrients. It also brings three hazards that compost made from leaves and kitchen scraps does not: disease organisms that make people sick, herbicide residues that deform vegetables, and a load of phosphorus and salts that builds up with every application.

The working rule is short. Unless manure has been hot-composted to a known standard, treat it as raw: spread it in fall, dig it in, and allow at least 120 days before you harvest any crop that touches the soil and 90 days before you harvest anything else. Never side-dress growing vegetables with it, and never use dog, cat or pig manure at all.

What manure supplies

These are average analyses of solid manures from Utah State University Extension. Real loads vary widely with the amount and kind of bedding, moisture and how long the pile has sat, so use them to compare types, not to calculate to the ounce.

Manure Nitrogen % Phosphate % Potash % Salts (dS/m)
Turkey 3.1 2.9 1.7 10
Rabbit 2.3 1.1 0.4 1
Chicken 2.0 2.7 1.4 16
Sheep 1.0 0.5 1.0 7
Beef cattle 0.9 0.6 1.1 8
Dairy cattle 0.8 0.5 1.2 10
Horse 0.7 0.4 1.1 3

The rabbit figures rest on only a few samples. Poultry manure is the richest and the saltiest. Horse and cattle manure are mild and are worth more as organic matter than as fertilizer.

Two things lower what the plants get. First, only part of the nitrogen is available in the first year: about half if the manure is dug in at once and about 30 percent if it is left on the surface, with more released over the following years, up to three. Second, bedding dilutes it. Manure with a lot of straw, sawdust or wood shavings has so much carbon (a carbon-to-nitrogen ratio above about 25 or 30 to 1) that the microbes breaking it down take nitrogen out of the soil for a while instead of adding it.

Fresh, aged and composted are three different things

  • Fresh manure is high in ammonia and soluble salts, which burn roots and seedlings, and carries live pathogens and weed seeds.
  • Aged manure has sat in a pile. It smells better and burns less, but "aged" and "rotted" are not regulated terms, a pile that just sat was never turned so that all of it heated, and University of New Hampshire Extension states plainly that the pathogens in aged manure cannot be assumed destroyed. Aged is not composted.
  • Composted manure went through a managed process. The US organic standard requires a starting carbon-to-nitrogen ratio between 25:1 and 40:1 and a temperature between 131°F and 170°F for 3 days in an enclosed or aerated system, or for 15 days in a turned windrow with at least five turnings, so that all of the material is heated. A home pile qualifies only if you measured it holding that heat through repeated turnings; see composting.
  • Bagged manure from a store may have been composted or pasteurized. The package should say whether it is pathogen-free; if it does not, treat it as raw.

Composting has a cost: some nitrogen is lost, so composted manure feeds less than fresh, and the salts can be more concentrated.

Pathogens and the 120/90-day rule

Manure can carry E. coli O157:H7, Salmonella, Listeria and Campylobacter, the parasites Giardia and Cryptosporidium, and roundworms and tapeworms. They reach people on raw produce. Research cited by University of New Hampshire Extension found that working manure into the soil at least 120 days before harvest greatly reduces the risk.

The rule gardeners borrow comes from the federal organic standard, which requires raw manure to be worked into the soil:

  • at least 120 days before harvest of any crop whose edible part touches the soil or is splashed by it: root crops, leafy greens, strawberries, onions, potatoes;
  • at least 90 days before harvest of crops whose edible part does not touch the soil, such as staked tomatoes and peppers.

Count back from harvest and the conclusion is that raw or aged manure belongs in the garden in fall. Lettuce, spinach and radishes are harvested a month or two after sowing, so a spring application can never satisfy the rule for them.

  • Dig it in. Manure worked into the soil carries much less risk than manure lying on the surface.
  • Never side-dress with raw manure, and once the garden is planted, use no manure that has not been properly composted or pasteurized.
  • Wash and peel. Rinse all produce in clean drinking-quality water, peel root crops, and wash your hands after handling manure or soil. Cooking kills what washing leaves.
  • Know who is eating. Pregnant women, very young children, the elderly and people with chronic illness should not eat uncooked vegetables from a garden that gets raw manure.

Manures never to use

Dog, cat and pig manure carry parasites that are more likely than those of other animals to survive and infect people. Keep them out of the vegetable garden and out of the compost pile.

Salts and seedling burn

Fresh manure, poultry above all, is salty; chicken manure in the Utah table carries five times the salts of horse manure. Vegetables start to suffer when soil salinity passes about 2 dS/m. Dig manure in 6 to 8 inches so it is diluted, wait three to four weeks after spreading fresh poultry manure before planting, and wait about a month after a spring application of composted manure before sowing seed. Rain leaches salts away in humid regions; in dry climates they accumulate, which is one more reason to keep rates modest.

Weed seeds

Fresh manure often carries live weed seeds. Horse manure is the worst, because seeds pass through a horse intact. Hot composting can kill them (Wisconsin gives 145°F); a cool pile will not.

Phosphorus builds up

Manure holds more phosphorus and potassium, relative to its nitrogen, than crops remove. If you spread enough to meet a crop's nitrogen need every year, soil phosphorus climbs year after year. High phosphorus does not poison plants or people, but it washes into streams and ponds and feeds algae.

So test the soil every few years; see soil testing. University of New Hampshire Extension's guide is that manure and manure composts are fine while phosphorus is in the low to optimum range, and that once it is very high you should supply nutrients some other way. A low-phosphorus nitrogen source and a cover crop keep the garden productive in the meantime; see the fertilization guide.

Persistent herbicides

Horse and cattle manure can carry aminopyralid, clopyralid or picloram, weed-killers sprayed on pastures and hayfields. They pass through the animal unchanged, survive composting, and break down especially slowly inside a manure pile. Tiny amounts cup and twist the new leaves of tomatoes, peppers, potatoes, beans, peas and lettuce, and a contaminated bed can stay that way for a year or more, sometimes several.

Ask the supplier what the animals ate and whether the hay or pasture was sprayed. Then test before you spread: mix the manure half and half with potting mix in several pots, sow beans or peas, and compare them with plants in plain potting mix until they have three sets of true leaves. The full method is in hay vs straw mulching, and the symptoms and remedies are in herbicide damage in the garden.

How much and when

University of Wisconsin Extension gives these amounts per 100 square feet, each supplying about 0.2 pound of available nitrogen. A 5-gallon bucket holds about 25 pounds.

Manure Pounds per 100 square feet
Poultry, no litter 20
Poultry with litter 30
Poultry, composted 70
Sheep, no bedding 40
Sheep with bedding 50
Horse with bedding 65
Dairy cow, no bedding 75
Dairy cow with bedding 95
Dairy cow, composted 200
  • Don't exceed these rates. More means salt damage, leafy growth at the expense of fruit, and nitrate and phosphorus washing into groundwater and streams.
  • Spread raw or aged manure in fall, dig it in within 12 hours, and sow a cover crop over it where the season allows.
  • Use properly composted manure in spring or fall, and count it as your compost for the year, not as an extra. See building healthy soil for how much compost a bed needs.
  • Cut other fertilizer to match. Manure already supplies phosphorus and potassium, so anything you add on top should be mostly nitrogen.

Sources