Clubroot of Cabbage-Family Crops

Clubroot is a soil disease of the cabbage family. Plants wilt on warm afternoons, stay stunted and fail to head, and when you dig one up the roots are swollen into thick, knobby clubs. It affects every brassica, from cabbage and broccoli to radishes and arugula, and once it is in a bed its spores stay for many years.

That makes prevention the main job: clubroot almost always arrives in soil on transplants, tools or boots. Where it is already present there is no cure and no fungicide for home gardens, but a combination of lime to raise the soil pH above 7, a long break from the whole family, good drainage and resistant varieties keeps it low enough to grow a crop.

The organism and its life cycle

Clubroot is caused by Plasmodiophora brassicae. It was once called a slime mold or a primitive fungus and is now classed as a protist. It can grow only inside the living roots of a host plant.

  1. Thick-walled resting spores lie dormant in the soil.
  2. Root secretions from a host plant trigger them to germinate. Each releases a swimming spore that moves through soil water and enters a root hair.
  3. Inside the root the organism multiplies and releases a second wave of swimming spores, which invade the main root tissue of the same plant and its neighbors.
  4. The infection alters the plant's hormones and the infected cells swell. Galls become visible four to six weeks after planting.
  5. The organism turns into millions of new resting spores inside each gall. When the gall rots, they are released into the soil.

Because the spores swim, infection needs wet soil. It is favored by soil that is acidic (below about pH 6.5), wet and warm: spores germinate poorly below about 57°F, the disease slows below 63°F, and it develops fastest at 73 to 79°F. Low, poorly drained spots show it first.

Symptoms

Above ground: stunted plants; leaves that turn dull blue-green, yellow or purplish; wilting on warm days even when the soil is moist, with recovery at night; heads that stay small or never form. Young plants infected early may die. Lightly infected plants can look normal while still adding spores to the soil.

Below ground: swollen, distorted roots. On cabbage, broccoli and other fibrous-rooted crops the roots thicken into spindle-shaped clubs or a coral-like mass. On turnips, rutabagas and radishes, galls form on the taproot and side roots. Fresh galls are firm and white inside; old ones turn brown and rot.

Dig suspect plants with a fork. Do not pull them, because the galls break off and stay behind.

Look-alikes

Problem Roots Notes
Clubroot Spindle- or club-shaped swellings that can reach several inches across; no insects inside Cabbage family only
Root-knot nematodes Smaller, rounder knots strung along the roots Less common on brassicas than clubroot
Cabbage root maggot No swellings; roots chewed, tunneled or gone, with maggots or small brown pupae in or beside them Plants also wilt on sunny days and turn yellow or purple
Drought, wet feet, other root rots Roots normal in shape, or brown and decayed without swelling

If you are unsure, a university plant diagnostic clinic can confirm it. That is worth doing before you commit to years of liming and rotation.

Hosts

Every crop in the cabbage family is a host: cabbage, broccoli, cauliflower, Brussels sprouts, kale, collards, kohlrabi, Chinese cabbage, bok choy, turnips, rutabagas, radishes, arugula, mustard greens and broccoli raab. Cabbage, Chinese cabbage and Brussels sprouts are among the most susceptible.

So are the family's weeds and relatives: shepherd's purse, wild mustards and wild radish, and ornamentals such as wallflowers, stocks and aubrieta. Mustard and forage radish cover crops are hosts too; do not sow them where clubroot is a risk. Sweet alyssum has not shown clubbing.

Rotation plans most often go wrong on the small crops. A row of radishes, arugula or mustard greens in the "off" years keeps the disease going as surely as cabbage does.

How it arrives

Clubroot is not carried in seed. It travels as resting spores in soil:

  • Transplants. The most common route into a new garden: purchased or gift plants raised in infested soil, or flats set down on infested ground to harden off. Infected seedlings show no swellings for about three weeks.
  • Soil on tools, tillers, boots and wheelbarrows, including borrowed and shared ones, and on the feet of livestock.
  • Water. Runoff, floodwater and irrigation water drawn from a pond that takes runoff from an infested field.
  • Compost that included infected roots and did not heat through.
  • Wind-blown soil, over short distances.

How long it lasts

Resting spores have been recorded surviving up to about 20 years. Most die much sooner: the measured half-life is about 3.6 years, so roughly half are gone after four years and three-quarters after eight. Eradication is not realistic. The goal is to get the spore numbers low and keep them from building up again.

What works

Keep it out.

  • Raise your own transplants in bagged soilless mix and clean or new trays, and never set the trays down on garden soil.
  • If you buy plants, check the roots. If any plant in a batch has swellings, reject the whole batch.
  • Clean tools and boots that have been in another garden or a community plot: knock off the soil, wash, then disinfect with diluted household bleach (extension recipes run from a 1 or 2 percent bleach solution to 1 part bleach in 9 of water).
  • Do not accept soil, compost or brassica plants from a garden that has it.

Raise the pH. Lime does not kill the spores; a pH above 7 stops most of them from germinating. The details decide whether it works:

  • Target pH 7.2 or a little higher, measured by a laboratory soil test. Extension targets run from 7.0 to 7.5. In Oregon field trials liming had little or no effect when the soil did not reach 7.0 by planting.
  • It takes more lime than usual. Soil resists change above about pH 6.4; in Oregon's soils each step up took about 1.4 times as much lime as the same step lower down. Have the lab calculate the amount from a buffer test and tell them your target.
  • Use finely ground calcitic limestone unless the soil test shows low magnesium. Dolomitic lime and coarse or pelleted products react more slowly. Hydrated lime acts within days but is caustic to handle.
  • Apply it well ahead: at least a month before planting, and better the fall before. Retest before planting.
  • Mix it in thoroughly through the top 6 to 8 inches, tilling or digging twice. Roots are infected in any pocket of soil that stayed below pH 7. In an Oregon trial, lime with a single tilling cut the share of infected plants from 59 to 35 percent; lime tilled in twice cut it to 8 percent.
  • The trade-off is boron, which becomes less available as pH rises. Brassicas are the crops that show a shortage first: hollow stems and brown curds in cauliflower, brown heart in rutabagas. Watch for it, mostly on sandy soil, and add boron only on a soil test, because a little too much is toxic. Potatoes get more scab as pH climbs, so keep them out of a bed limed for clubroot. More in soil pH.

Even done well, liming reduces clubroot; it does not eliminate it.

Take a long break. Keep every host crop out of an infested bed for five to seven years, and keep cabbage-family weeds out of it for the whole time. Oregon State's records from farms show that rotations shorter than four or five years risk serious losses.

Improve drainage. Raised beds and breaking up compacted layers reduce the wet soil the swimming spores need. Do not overwater. Switching from sprinklers to drip did not reduce clubroot on Oregon farms; it is waterlogging that matters. A raised bed filled with clean soil lets you grow brassicas in an infested garden.

Plant resistant varieties. They are few, but they exist for most crops, and seed is the cheapest control of all. Varieties with resistance confirmed in Oregon State's trials or listed by Cornell or the Royal Horticultural Society:

Crop Varieties
Cabbage 'Kilaton', 'Tekila', 'Kilagreg'; red 'Lodero'
Chinese (napa) cabbage 'Bilko', 'Emiko', 'China Gold', 'Yuki'
Broccoli 'Emerald Jewel', 'Monclano'
Cauliflower 'Clapton', 'Clarify'
Brussels sprouts 'Crispus'

In the Oregon trials these had 0 to 15 percent of plants infected where ordinary varieties had 88 to 100 percent. None was completely immune. Clubroot exists as different strains, a variety that resists one may not resist another, and growing resistant varieties over and over in the same soil selects for strains that overcome them. Use them along with lime and rotation. The kohlrabi, bok choy and turnip varieties tested showed little or no resistance.

Start with bigger plants in cool soil. Plants infected young suffer most. The Royal Horticultural Society advises growing transplants on in pots at least 3.5 inches wide so they go out with a large healthy root system. Crops that grow while the soil is still below about 60°F, in early spring and late fall, are infected more slowly.

What does not work

  • A three- or four-year rotation. It is the right interval for most brassica problems and too short for this one.
  • Fungicide drenches. No effective fungicide is available to home gardeners. The products farms use at planting give inconsistent results even there.
  • Lime tossed on top at planting, or lime that does not get the pH to 7.
  • Mustard "biofumigant" cover crops. They are hosts.
  • Resting the bed under weeds. Shepherd's purse and wild mustard keep the cycle going.

What to do with infected plants

Dig them, roots and all, as soon as you find them and before the galls rot. Bag them and put them in the trash, or bury them well away from the garden. Do not put them on the compost pile: spores survive in the cooler, drier parts of a home pile. (Minnesota's extension service allows composting them on site, but only in a pile that reaches 148°F.) Then clean the fork and your boots before you walk into the next bed.

See the cabbage family in the garden for the family's other shared pests and diseases.

Sources