Growing Onions in the Home Garden

A bulb onion (Allium cepa) grows leaves until the days reach a set length, then stops making leaves and swells the bases of the ones it has into a bulb. Two decisions follow from that and matter more than anything else you do: choose a variety whose day-length trigger matches your latitude, and plant early enough that the plant is large when the trigger comes.

Onions are in the onion family with garlic, leeks and chives. For onions pulled young, see growing green onions.

Pick the day-length class for your latitude

Class Starts to bulb at Latitude Examples
Short-day 10 to 12 hours of daylight About 25° to 35°: the South, planted in fall or winter 'Texas Grano 1015Y', 'Granex 33', 'Yellow Granex', 'White Bermuda'
Intermediate (day-neutral) 12 to 14 hours About 32° to 42°: the middle of the country 'Candy', 'Juno', 'MidStar'
Long-day 14 to 16 hours About 37° to 47°: the North 'Yellow Sweet Spanish', 'White Sweet Spanish', 'Southport Red Globe'; the storage onions recommended in northern states, such as 'Copra', 'Patterson' and 'Redwing'

The bands overlap, and seed catalogs give the class for every variety. With the wrong class, a long-day onion in the South never gets its signal and makes leaves but no bulb. A short-day onion in the North gets its signal in late winter, when the plant is tiny, and makes a small bulb early. Oregon State's example: an 11-hour onion in Salem, Oregon, would start to bulb on February 25, a 15-hour onion on May 18.

Why early planting makes big onions

A bulb is made of swollen leaf bases, so its size is set by how many leaves the plant has, and how big they are, on the day bulbing starts. A well-grown onion has 8 to 12 leaves by then. The day-length trigger arrives on the same date whether you planted in April or in late May, so the late planting bulbs with fewer, smaller leaves. Nothing you do afterward makes up for it.

Seed, transplants or sets

  • Transplants (your own or bought in bundles) are the best route to large bulbs in most gardens. Sow seed indoors 10 to 12 weeks before you plan to plant out, a quarter inch deep, and grow the seedlings cool and bright. Aim for plants about a quarter inch thick, thinner than a pencil.
  • Direct seed as soon as the soil can be worked. It gives the widest choice of varieties, but in the North a sowing made after about mid-May does not have time to size up before bulbing starts.
  • Sets are small bulbs grown the year before. They are the easiest to plant and give the earliest green onions, but the choice is two or three unnamed types, and they are more likely to bolt than seed-grown plants because they are already in their second year. Small sets are the ones to plant for bulbs: sort them, keep those under about half to three quarters of an inch (smaller than a dime or nickel) for bulbs, and plant the larger ones close together for green onions.

Trimming seedling tops. Extension guides recommend clipping seedlings back to 4 or 5 inches when they flop in the tray and again at planting. The reason they give is practical: shorter tops lose less water while the roots take hold. None of the guides claims it makes larger bulbs, so do not trim harder than you need to keep plants manageable.

Planting

Onions tolerate light frost. Set transplants and sets out as soon as the soil can be worked, about four weeks before your last frost date (look it up with the zone and frost date lookup). In the South, short-day onions are planted in fall or winter instead.

Plant transplants about 1 inch deep and sets 1 to 1-1/2 inches deep. Space plants 3 to 4 inches apart in rows 12 to 18 inches apart; 4 to 6 inches gives larger bulbs. Do not hill soil around bulb onions. They push up out of the ground as they swell, and that is normal.

Soil, water and feeding

Onions want full sun and loose, well-drained soil with a pH of 6.0 to 7.0. They do poorly in acid soil. Work in compost, and use a soil test to decide on phosphorus and potassium.

  • Water: the roots are shallow, mostly in the top 6 to 8 inches. Give 1 inch a week and do not let the bed dry out while bulbs are swelling. Stop when the bulbs are full size and the tops begin to fall.
  • Weeds: thin onion leaves shade nothing. Weed shallowly and often, especially in the first two months, and mulch between rows.
  • Nitrogen: side-dress once or twice while the plants are growing leaves, then stop once bulbing begins. Late nitrogen delays maturity and gives thick necks, soft bulbs and poor keeping.
  • Sulfur and pungency: the bite of an onion comes from sulfur compounds. Onions grown in low-sulfur soil are milder, which is the basis of the Vidalia onion, and extra sulfur or dry soil makes them hotter. For mild onions, grow a sweet variety and do not let the bed go dry while the bulbs swell.

Bolting

An onion that sends up a flower stalk has bolted, and day length is not the cause. Cold is: roughly three to four weeks below 50°F on a plant that already has about five leaves. Tiny seedlings are not affected, which is why oversized transplants and large sets are the ones that bolt, and why a cold spring after early planting brings more of it.

Cutting the stalk off does little. Pull bolted onions and eat them now; the thick neck is hard to cure and they do not keep. The full explanation is on the bolting page.

Harvest: wait for the tops to fall

When the bulb is mature the neck softens and the top falls over by itself. Harvest storage onions when half to most of the tops are down, on a dry day, lifting with a fork.

Bending the tops over by hand to "ripen" the bulbs is old advice, and sources differ on it. University of Illinois Extension says breaking the tops over early interrupts growth and gives smaller bulbs that do not keep as well, and Iowa State notes that broken or cut tops let black mold in. A Pacific Northwest extension guide allows rolling the tops down once most have already fallen, to speed drying. Nothing is gained by doing it earlier than that.

Curing and storage

Cure onions out of the sun in a warm, airy place (75°F to 90°F is ideal), spread in a single layer, for two to four weeks. They are done when the necks are tight and completely dry and the outer skins rustle. Then cut the tops to about an inch, or braid them.

Store at 32°F to 40°F and 65 to 70 percent humidity, in mesh bags or crates. Onions sprout if kept above 40°F for long, and rot if damp.

How long they keep depends mostly on type:

  • Pungent, hard, long-day storage onions ('Copra', 'Patterson', 'Redwing') keep for months: six to nine in commercial cold storage at 32°F.
  • Sweet and mild onions ('Walla Walla', 'Candy', 'Ailsa Craig', and the short-day Granex types) keep only a few weeks.
  • Use first: anything thick-necked, bruised or bolted.

Pests and diseases

Do not grow onions or their relatives in the same bed more than once in three to four years. That one habit limits most of what follows.

  • Onion maggot: white maggots tunnel into seedlings and bulbs; plants yellow, wilt and rot. Worst in the North. The first of three generations does the most damage. Cover spring plantings with row cover, rotate, and remove culls and debris. Nothing helps once maggots are inside.
  • Onion thrips: silvery streaks and brown leaf tips in hot, dry weather, and smaller bulbs when heavy. Red onions are hit hardest and Sweet Spanish types least. Thrips hide deep in the leaf bases, so sprays reach them poorly; overhead watering knocks numbers down.
  • Allium leafminer: a newer pest in the Mid-Atlantic and southern New England. Bulb onions are the allium least at risk, and seeded onions less than transplants. See growing leeks.
  • Pink root: roots turn pink, then dark red, and die; bulbs stay small. The fungus is most active in soil at 75°F to 85°F and lasts for years. Utah State University Extension rates resistant varieties as the best answer, and finds that growing onions in a bed only one year in five keeps it low.
  • Downy mildew: pale patches with fuzzy violet growth in cool, damp weather, then yellow, collapsing leaves. Space plants for air flow and go easy on nitrogen. See downy mildew.
  • Purple blotch: sunken, purple-zoned spots with a yellow halo in warm, wet weather.
  • Botrytis neck rot: shows up in storage as a soft, brown, sunken rot starting at the neck. The fungus enters through necks that were still green. Stop feeding and watering late, let tops dry fully, and cure well.

Shallots

Shallots are a form of the same species that divides: each bulb planted makes a cluster. Traditional shallots are grown from saved bulbs, planted in fall in the South or early spring in the North, 6 to 8 inches apart and 1 to 2 inches deep. The new bulbs often form on top of the ground; do not cover them. Hybrid shallots that are grown from seed like onions are now sold as well; 'Ambition' and 'Conservor' are two varieties listed for New England. Harvest when the tops have died down, cure like onions, and expect them to keep longer than onions do.

Pets

Onions are toxic to dogs, cats and horses, raw or cooked. They damage red blood cells and cause vomiting, weakness and anemia. Keep bulbs, trimmings and table scraps away from pets.

Sources