Slugs and Snails

Slugs and snails feed at night and hide by day, so the damage usually shows up before the culprit does: ragged holes in leaves, seedlings eaten to stubs, and a dried, silvery slime trail that settles the question.

What works is a combination: make the bed drier and barer, trap and hand-pick, and use an iron phosphate bait where seedlings or favorite plants need protecting. The barriers gardeners most often try, including copper tape, crushed eggshells, grit and wool pellets, made no difference to damage in a Royal Horticultural Society garden trial.

How they live

Slugs are snails without a shell, and both move on a film of mucus that they must keep from drying out. That one fact explains most of the advice on this page. They feed at night and on cloudy, damp days, and spend sunny days under boards, stones, mulch, debris, dense ground covers and low leaves.

Every slug and snail is both male and female and all of them lay eggs. Slugs lay clear, round to oval eggs in batches of 3 to 40 under leaves, in soil cracks and in other sheltered spots, and are mature in three to six months. The brown garden snail, the common garden snail of California, lays about 80 eggs at a time in a hole in the soil, up to six times a year, and takes about two years to mature. In cold-winter areas slugs get through winter mostly as eggs in the soil and under debris; in mild climates they can be active all year. The gray garden slug (Deroceras reticulatum) is one of the usual pest species.

Confirming slug damage

  • Holes are irregular with smooth edges, in the middle of leaves as well as at the margins, and in flowers and low fruit such as strawberries and tomatoes that touch the ground.
  • Seedlings are clipped off or vanish overnight. Cutworms also take seedlings overnight; they cut the stem at the soil line and leave no slime.
  • Slime trails on leaves, soil or paving confirm it. Caterpillars and earwigs chew similar holes but leave no slime; caterpillars leave dark droppings instead.
  • Go out after dark with a flashlight on a damp evening and you will see them feeding.

Light feeding on established plants is cosmetic. Seedlings and new transplants are where slugs cost you plants.

Make the garden less inviting

These changes do the most good and cost nothing:

  • Water in the morning, not the evening, so the soil surface and leaves are dry by night. Drip lines or soaker hoses wet far less surface than sprinklers.
  • Remove daytime shelter near vulnerable beds: boards, flat stones, empty pots, weedy edges and plant debris.
  • Keep mulch thin around seedlings. Too much chopped-leaf mulch encourages slugs; take off the excess in spring. See mulching the garden.
  • Let in light and air. Thin and divide crowded plants, stake floppy ones and take off leaves lying on the soil.
  • Cultivate lightly in spring to bring eggs to the surface, where they dry out.
  • Check under covers. The humid air under row covers and netting suits slugs.

Traps and hand-picking

Boards. Lay boards, shingles or damp newspaper on the soil. Slugs gather underneath by morning; scrape them into soapy water. A board about 12 by 15 inches raised an inch off the ground on runners works well. Upturned melon or citrus rinds do the same job. Check daily.

Beer traps drown slugs, but University of California IPM notes they draw slugs from only a few feet away. To work at all they need steep sides, enough liquid to drown in, and refilling every few days. Yeast in sugar water can be used instead of beer.

Hand-picking is effective if you keep at it. Water the bed in late afternoon, go out after dark with a flashlight and gloves, and drop what you find into soapy water. Do it nightly at first, then weekly once numbers fall.

Barriers: what trials show

Barrier Evidence
Copper tape or strip Wide bands can turn slugs back: UC recommends strips 4 to 6 inches wide and notes they stop working when tarnished. Minnesota says narrow copper tape is often ineffective. In the RHS trial copper tape did not reduce damage.
Crushed eggshells Not shown to work (UC); no effect in the RHS trial.
Coffee grounds Not shown to work (UC).
Sharp grit, pine bark, wool pellets No effect in the RHS trial.
Diatomaceous earth Works only while dry, in a band about 3 inches wide and an inch high. Minnesota calls it "generally not an effective slug deterrent."
Salt Do not use it. It kills the slug you sprinkle and adds salt to your soil.

The RHS trial grew 108 lettuces in pots and raised beds for six weeks, each ringed with copper tape, crushed eggshells, sharp grit, pine bark mulch or wool pellets, or left unprotected. The protected lettuces were damaged just as much as the unprotected ones. Laboratory studies have shown that some barriers repel slugs, copper especially, so the researchers do not rule barriers out, but in a garden setting they did not hold up.

Household ammonia diluted to 5 to 10 percent appears in UC's advice only for killing slugs you have collected, not as a spray for plants.

Baits

Baits protect seedlings while the other measures bring numbers down. They do not give lasting control on their own, and they kill every kind of slug and snail, harmless native ones included.

  • Iron phosphate is the one to use. Slugs stop feeding soon after eating it and die over the next several days, usually out of sight, so do not expect to see bodies. It stays effective for about two weeks, even when wet. Some products are approved for organic growing. In tests it did not affect earthworms or ground beetles and is practically non-toxic to birds.
  • Ferric sodium EDTA is a different iron bait that kills in about three days instead of seven. It is not approved for organic use.
  • Sulfur baits reduce feeding, but less than the iron baits.
  • Metaldehyde kills quickly but is poisonous to dogs and cats, which are attracted to the pellets, and to birds. Slugs can also recover from it in cool, wet weather. Great Britain phased out outdoor use by March 2022 because of the risk to birds and mammals. With iron baits available there is little reason to use it in a home garden.

"Pet safe" on an iron bait does not mean harmless. The National Pesticide Information Center notes that dogs have become sick after eating large amounts of iron from slug baits, fertilizers and vitamins, and cites a veterinary report of poisoning in five dogs that ate an iron EDTA bait. Scatter pellets thinly, never in piles, sweep up spills and store the box where a dog cannot reach it.

Apply bait in the evening after watering lightly, around the plants you are protecting and near hiding places. The RHS goes further and advises against all slug pellets, organic ones included, because of effects on garden wildlife.

Natural enemies and nematodes

Ground beetles, rove beetles, firefly larvae, toads, snakes and birds all eat slugs or their eggs, and leaving them habitat helps (leaving stems and leaves for overwintering insects). On their own they rarely keep slugs below damaging levels. Ducks, geese or chickens penned in the garden can reduce slugs significantly, but seedlings have to be protected from the birds.

Gardeners in Europe water on a slug-killing nematode, Phasmarhabditis hermaphrodita, sold as Nemaslug. It is not an option in the United States. A 2022 study reported that the commercial strain had not been approved here and was still not commercially available, although the nematode itself has been found living in California nurseries and in Oregon. The beneficial nematodes that are sold in the US are for soil insects, not slugs (buying beneficial insects).

Plants slugs prefer and avoid

Slugs favor hosta, delphinium, dahlias, marigolds, bellflower, daylily, lettuce, basil, beans, cabbage and strawberries. They rarely bother plants grown in full sun and dry soil, woody plants or ornamental grasses. Seldom-damaged choices include lavender, rosemary, sage, yarrow, lantana, asters, coneflowers, sedum, bee balm, iris, astilbe, coral bells, bleeding heart and ferns.

For other pests, see garden pests.

Sources