Buying Beneficial Insects: What Works and What Doesn't

Most beneficial insects bought for an open garden are money spent on something that leaves. University of California IPM's summary is that there has been little research on releases in gardens and landscapes, and that they "are unlikely to provide satisfactory pest control in most situations."

Two kinds of purchase do have evidence behind them: natural enemies released in an enclosed space such as a greenhouse or a room of houseplants, and beneficial nematodes watered into soil for a pest they are known to kill. Outdoors, you get more from feeding and sparing the predators that are already there.

At a glance

Product What research shows Worth buying for a garden?
Lady beetles (ladybugs) About 95% fly away within 48 hours; wild-collected, and carry parasites No
Praying mantis egg cases Eat pests, pollinators and each other; do not prevent damage No
Green lacewing eggs or larvae Larvae stay while there is prey; aphid control only with large numbers Sometimes, on a small scale
Trichogramma wasps Need the right species and repeated, timed releases No
Predatory mites Reliable in greenhouses; outdoors only where spider mites are present and humidity suits Indoors and greenhouses
Mealybug destroyer Works on heavy mealybug infestations indoors; dies in cold winters Indoors and greenhouses
Beneficial nematodes Kill specific soil insects when soil is warm and moist Yes, for the right pest

Lady beetles

The ladybugs sold in bags are convergent lady beetles (Hippodamia convergens). They are not farmed. Collectors gather them from the huge clusters in which they spend the winter in California's foothills and mountains, and they are usually stored cold until sold.

In University of California studies about 95 percent of released beetles flew away within 48 hours, even when handled with care, and they were unlikely to lay eggs on the plants they were released on. Control was possible only with very large numbers: one large, heavily infested rose bush took two releases of about 1,500 beetles each, a week apart. A typical retail package holds enough for one shrub or a few small plants. UC's verdict is that most lady beetles bought in stores probably fail to give satisfactory control, and that hosing the aphids off or using insecticidal soap may do better.

Bought beetles also bring passengers. A study of 22 shipments from three commercial suppliers found a parasitic wasp of lady beetles, Dinocampus coccinellae, in every shipment (8 percent of beetles on average, up to 15 percent) and a microsporidian disease in 13 of the 22. In the laboratory that disease spreads to other lady beetle species. The author's conclusion was that releasing field-collected beetles releases their parasites and diseases too, and that the practice should be re-evaluated.

If you release them anyway: keep them refrigerated, mist the plants, and release at dusk at the base of infested plants that have not been sprayed.

Praying mantis egg cases

Most egg cases for sale are the Chinese mantid, which is not native to North America. Each case hatches 50 to 200 nymphs, which begin eating each other if food is short. Mantids do not tell pests from beneficial insects: Kansas State lists butterflies, moths, flies, wasps and honey bees among their prey, and large ones take hummingbirds. Its recommendation is not to buy egg cases for pest control, because mantids do not kill enough pests to prevent plant damage. University of Kentucky adds that extra egg cases may not even raise the population, since the young eat one another and move away.

Green lacewings

Lacewing larvae are effective predators: one has been recorded eating 100 to 600 aphids, and they also take mites, thrips, whiteflies and small caterpillars. They are sold as eggs or young larvae, and larvae tend to stay near where they are released as long as there is prey. That makes them more likely to stay than lady beetles. The limits: in trials on vegetables, aphid control came only with large numbers of lacewings, results varied, and once the larvae mature the adults fly off, often a long way, before laying eggs. The adults eat only nectar, pollen and honeydew, so flowers nearby matter more than a second shipment.

Trichogramma wasps

These tiny wasps lay their eggs inside the eggs of moths. Using them takes the right species for the pest and releases timed to egg laying and repeated every few days: adults of one well-studied species live only about three days without food. Even then results can disappoint: in sweet corn, releases that parasitized more than 80 percent of European corn borer egg masses still left too much damage. That is a farm program, not a one-time garden release.

Predatory mites

Phytoseiulus persimilis is a specialist predator of spider mites and is widely used in greenhouse vegetables. It needs humidity above 60 percent to survive and breed, and it starves or leaves once the spider mites are gone, so it suits greenhouses, sunrooms and indoor plants. The western predatory mite (Galendromus occidentalis) copes better with hot, dry conditions. University of California's guideline is one predator for every ten spider mites, released where the mites are, after knocking back a heavy infestation with a soap spray.

Outdoors, UC says the best results come from protecting the predatory mites already present. Dust, drought-stressed plants and broad-spectrum sprays such as carbaryl and pyrethroids are what set off spider mite outbreaks.

Mealybug destroyer and aphid parasites

The mealybug destroyer (Cryptolaemus montrouzieri) is a small lady beetle whose larvae look like mealybugs. It works best where mealybugs are numerous, as on greenhouse and indoor plants, and it cannot survive cold winters outdoors.

Parasitic wasps that attack aphids, such as Aphidius, are also sold, but UC's review does not list them among the releases with evidence behind them for gardens. Wild species find aphid colonies unaided; the swollen, tan "mummies" among the aphids are their work, and once mummies appear aphid numbers often drop sharply within a week or two. See aphids.

Beneficial nematodes

Insect-killing nematodes (Steinernema and Heterorhabditis) are microscopic worms that enter soil insects and kill them within a day or two. They are safe for people, pets and plants, and field studies have found no harm to beneficial insects. They work when three things are right.

The right species for the pest.

Nematode Pests it is used against
Heterorhabditis bacteriophora White grubs in lawns (results vary with the grub species), black vine weevil and other root weevils
Steinernema feltiae Fungus gnat larvae in potting mix, root maggots
Steinernema carpocapsae Cutworms, sod webworms, billbugs, flea larvae: insects at or near the soil surface

Warm, moist soil. As a general rule the soil should be between 55 and 90°F. H. bacteriophora loses effectiveness below about 68°F, so it is a poor choice for cold soil in spring or late fall; S. feltiae keeps working down to 50°F. Water before applying and keep the soil moist for at least two weeks afterward. Sunlight and drying kill the nematodes quickly, so apply in the evening or early morning and water them in. Sprayed onto leaves they die.

Live product. Nematodes are perishable. Refrigerated, they keep from one to several months depending on the product; a package left in a hot car may be dead. Order from a supplier that ships fresh and use them at once. The usual rate works out to roughly 23,000 nematodes per square foot (a billion per acre), and a repeat after a week is advised if damage continues.

For fungus gnats in houseplants, S. feltiae drenched into the pots gives lasting control if the mix stays moist and between 60 and 90°F; letting the surface dry between waterings is the other half of the cure. For Japanese beetle grubs, nematodes treat the lawn, not the beetles that fly in to your roses.

Why conservation beats purchase outdoors

A garden is open: released insects leave, and wild ones arrive whenever there is prey. What decides how many predators you have is whether they find food and shelter and survive your spraying.

  • Grow small flowers that feed the adults. Adult hoverflies, lacewings and parasitic wasps live on nectar and pollen; one Trichogramma species lived about 3 days without food and 14 when fed honey. In New Hampshire field trials in 2017 and 2018, sweet alyssum, buckwheat, cilantro and dill drew more hoverflies through the season than calendula, phacelia or fennel, and alyssum flowered continuously from July until frost. Two cautions from the same report: more work is needed to show that the hoverflies reduce pests on the crop, and alyssum also hosted flea beetles, so keep it away from young brassicas. Plant several kinds so something is in flower all season: dill and cilantro left to bloom do double duty.
  • Do not use broad-spectrum insecticides. They kill predators and parasites along with the pest, and the pest recovers first. If you must spray, soap and oil leave no residue once dry.
  • Tolerate a few pests. Predators stay only where there is something to eat.
  • Deal with ants, which guard aphids and other honeydew producers from their enemies.
  • Leave some cover. Predators need shelter as well as food; see leaving stems and leaves for overwintering insects.

When buying makes sense

  • In a greenhouse, sunroom or among houseplants, where the insects cannot leave.
  • Beneficial nematodes for a soil pest in the table above, in warm, moist soil.
  • When the pest is present but not yet heavy. UC notes that releases do poorly where pests or damage are already abundant.

For first steps against any pest, see garden pests.

Sources