Deer in the Garden: Fences, Repellents and Plant Choice

A fence is the only thing that reliably keeps deer out of a garden. The standard is woven or welded wire at least 8 feet tall; where deer pressure is moderate, a much cheaper electric fence baited with peanut butter protects a vegetable plot.

Everything else reduces damage without ending it. The best repellents cut browsing for a few weeks at a time and have to be reapplied, scare devices stop working once deer learn they are harmless, and "deer-resistant" plants are only the ones deer eat last.

Telling deer damage from rabbit damage

  • The cut. Deer have no upper front teeth, so they grip and tear. Browsed stems and leaves have jagged, shredded ends. Rabbits and rodents leave clean cuts.
  • The height. Deer browse from the ground up to about 6 feet.
  • Tracks and droppings. Deer leave heart-shaped hoof prints and piles of slightly elongated pellets about 3/4 inch long. Rabbit droppings are round.
  • The timing. Deer feed mostly in the early morning and late evening, so the damage often happens unseen. In the vegetable garden they graze plants to the ground, eat the tips off ears of sweet corn and trample what they do not eat.

For rabbits, a 2-foot fence of 1-inch chicken wire is enough; see garden pests.

Why some gardens are hit and others are not

How hard deer press on a garden depends on how many there are, what else there is to eat, how palatable your plants are, the weather, and whether they already have the habit of feeding there. A repellent or low fence that works where deer are few can fail where they are dense and hungry, and everything works better if it is in place before deer make your garden a regular stop.

Fencing

Adult deer can jump 7 feet or higher and will also crawl under a fence or squeeze through a gap, so height and a tight bottom edge both matter.

Fence Design Where it fits
Woven or welded wire At least 8 feet tall. Two 4-foot widths of welded wire, one above the other, on tall posts will do. Under heavy pressure, add two strands of wire above to reach 9 or 10 feet. Keep the bottom tight to the ground. Permanent, year-round protection. About $4 to $6 a foot for materials on a farm scale, and it lasts 20 years or more.
Solid wood or masonry 8 feet works in most cases, though deer can clear it. Small yards where rules allow.
Peanut butter fence One electrified wire 2.5 feet off the ground, with foil flags every 3 feet smeared with a half-and-half mix of peanut butter and vegetable oil. Deer nose the bait, get a shock on the nose and learn to stay away. Gardens up to about an acre under moderate pressure.
Electric polytape Two strands of white or yellow polytape at 1 foot and 3 feet (or one at 2.5 feet), with peanut butter smeared on the tape every 6 feet and renewed monthly. Vegetable gardens under moderate pressure. About 70 cents a foot. Take it down for winter.
3-D or slanted electric Two low electric fences about 5 feet apart, or several strands on posts angled outward at 45 degrees. Not deer-proof, but an effective deterrent in many gardens and cheaper than tall wire.
Individual cages and tubes Cylinders of chicken wire or woven wire, plastic netting over shrubs, or plastic tree tubes. Young trees and a few prized plants.

Notes that decide whether a fence works:

  • Electric fences teach; they do not block. They need a strong charger, must be on all the time (especially at night, and continuously for the first month), and need checking weekly because weeds touching the wire drain the charge. Put one up before deer are used to feeding in the plot; they work less well once the habit is set.
  • Short fences are for small spaces only. North Carolina's wildlife agency says a 4-foot fence may work only for very small areas or for individual trees and shrubs.
  • Netting draped over plants can entangle birds and snakes; keep it taut and check it (row covers and netting).

Repellents

Two controlled trials are worth knowing.

In USDA Forest Service pen tests of 20 commercial repellents on captive black-tailed deer, no product stopped browsing completely. The ones that smell of sulfur, mainly those based on rotten (putrescent) egg, were the most effective: the best gave close to full protection for about four weeks and good protection for 8 to 12 weeks. Bitter-tasting products "have proven ineffective in most trials," hot pepper (capsaicin) products did poorly, and repellents sprayed on the plants beat "area" repellents hung nearby.

In a two-year Connecticut trial of ten products on yews, none prevented all damage. Bobbex did best, with Hinder close behind at a fraction of the cost. Plants treated with Repellex tablets, Deer Solution, coyote urine and Plantskydd ended up no bigger than untreated ones. Products that were applied more often did better. Note that Plantskydd was among the better performers in the Forest Service tests; results for the same product differ from one trial to the next.

In practice:

  • Start early and keep it up. Spray before browsing starts or at the first sign, respray on the label's schedule, after heavy rain, and as new growth appears.
  • Check that the label allows use on food crops before spraying vegetables or fruit. Ammonium-soap products such as Hinder are labeled for fruit and vegetables. Never put predator urine on edible parts.
  • A home mix. University of Connecticut gives a recipe of a dozen eggs blended into 5 gallons of water (keep the shells out), sprayed on and renewed after every rain.
  • Change products and combine methods. Deer get used to most things.

Scare devices and dogs

Noise makers, lights and other scare devices give erratic, short-lived results because deer learn quickly that they are harmless; Nebraska Extension rates propane cannons and similar devices ineffective for that reason. Devices triggered by motion last longer than ones on a timer, and moving them helps. A motion-sensing sprinkler is useful short-term help for a summer vegetable garden if you keep moving it, not a substitute for a fence.

A dog that is outside and free to patrol, kept in by a fence or a buried-wire system, does keep deer away. A tethered dog is less use: deer learn to stay just out of its reach.

Soap, hair and other folk repellents

  • Bars of scented soap hung from stakes or branches are a traditional repellent, but deer become accustomed to the smell.
  • Human hair in mesh bags has given erratic results.
  • Predator urine weathers quickly; coyote urine did no better than no treatment in the Connecticut trial.
  • Blood meal or bone meal in small bags may work for a limited time.

Plant choice

Rutgers rates more than 500 landscape plants from A (rarely damaged) to D (frequently severely damaged) in its deer-resistance list. Use it to choose trees, shrubs and perennials, and plant the least palatable ones along the edge where deer enter. Two limits: Rutgers itself says no plant is deer proof and that results depend on the local deer population and the weather, and plants rated C or D should only be planted with a fence or repellent. The flower profiles on this site give a deer-resistance score for each plant; see the flower guide.

Plant choice does little for a vegetable garden. Fence it.

Antler rubbing on young trees

Bucks rub their antlers on young trees from September, when the velvet dries, through the fall rut, which peaks in early November. Rubbing strips the bark and can girdle and kill the tree. This is a different problem from browsing. Put a plastic tree tube or a cylinder of wire fencing around each young trunk by late summer.

Deer and ticks

Deer are important to the reproduction of the blacklegged (deer) tick, the tick that carries Lyme disease. The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station reports that keeping deer out of large areas lowers tick numbers: 300 feet inside an electric deer fence, tick larvae, nymphs and adults were down by 100, 85 and 74 percent. It also cautions that fencing a small area probably would not do as much without other steps. On lawns, 82 percent of deer ticks were found within 9 feet of the edge, so check yourself for ticks after working along the borders of the yard, fence or no fence.

Sources