Aphids

Aphids are small, soft-bodied insects that suck plant sap. Every garden has them every year, and most of the time lady beetles, hoverfly larvae, lacewings and tiny parasitic wasps bring a colony down without any help. University of Minnesota Extension puts it plainly: treating aphids for the health of the plant is usually unnecessary.

Step in when seedlings or new transplants are being stunted, when a colony keeps growing and you can find no predators on it, or when the crop itself is being fouled, as with cabbage aphids in fall Brussels sprouts and kale. Start with a hard spray of water. Broad-spectrum insecticides tend to make aphid problems worse, for reasons explained below.

Identification

Aphids are 1/16 to 1/8 inch long and pear-shaped, in green, black, red, yellow, brown or gray, with a pair of "tailpipes" (cornicles) at the rear. They cluster on new growth, buds and the undersides of leaves, mostly wingless. White flecks under a colony are their shed skins.

Why they multiply so fast

Through spring and summer every aphid in a colony is female, and she gives birth to live young without mating. University of California figures: as many as 12 young a day, each able to start reproducing in seven to eight days in warm weather, so one adult can leave up to 80 offspring within a week. Cabbage aphids can run through up to 15 generations in a season.

When a colony gets crowded or the plant declines, the next young grow wings and leave. They are poor fliers but travel for miles on the wind. In fall many species produce males and egg-laying females, and the eggs spend the winter on plants, in some species on a different, usually perennial, host from the summer one.

Most species do their worst damage in late spring, at about 65 to 80°F, and fade in midsummer heat. The cabbage aphid is the exception: it reproduces fastest at 50 to 68°F and peaks in late summer and fall.

Common garden aphids

Aphid Where you find it How to know it
Green peach aphid (Myzus persicae) Hundreds of plants, including peppers, potatoes and cabbage Yellowish green, with long cornicles
Melon or cotton aphid (Aphis gossypii) Many plants, especially cucumbers, watermelons and other vine crops By its host
Cabbage aphid (Brevicoryne brassicae) Cabbage-family crops only Grayish white from a waxy coating, short cornicles, dense colonies
Potato aphid (Macrosiphum euphorbiae) Potatoes, tomatoes, peppers and eggplant By its host
Bean aphid (Aphis fabae) Beans and other vegetables and flowers By its host
Woolly aphids Apple (roots and limbs), elm, young serviceberry, ash Hidden under white, waxy fluff
Oleander aphid (Aphis nerii) Milkweeds Bright yellow with black legs

Damage

Feeding. Low to moderate numbers on leaves usually do no harm. Large colonies yellow the leaves and stunt the shoots, and some species inject a toxin that curls and twists new growth. Curled leaves then shelter the aphids from sprays.

Honeydew and sooty mold. Aphids excrete a sticky, sugary liquid called honeydew that coats leaves and draws ants and yellowjackets. A black fungus, sooty mold, grows on it. The mold does not infect the plant and washes off with the honeydew.

Viruses. Aphids carry plant viruses such as cucumber mosaic virus from plant to plant; infected plants have mottled, yellowed or curled leaves and sometimes misshapen fruit. Killing the aphids does not prevent this. University of California IPM notes that very few aphids can infect a plant and that transmission takes only minutes, faster than any insecticide acts (plant pathologists call this non-persistent transmission). What helps is keeping aphids from landing: silver reflective mulch repels them and reduces aphid-borne viruses in squash and melons (take it up in the heat of summer), row cover protects young plants, and weeds such as sowthistle and wild mustards, which harbor aphids, are worth pulling.

Ants. Ants collect honeydew and in return drive off the aphids' predators. On trees, a sticky band around the trunk (over a wrap of fabric or tape on thin bark) keeps ants out, and ant bait stations work without harming the predators.

Natural enemies and how to read the signs

Look before you spray. These are the signs that help has arrived:

  • Mummies. Swollen, crusty, tan to bronze aphid shells stuck to the leaf. Each holds the young of a parasitic wasp. Once mummies appear, aphid numbers may drop substantially within a week or two.
  • Lady beetle larvae. Dark, elongated and spiny-looking, nothing like the adults, working through the colony. Adults eat aphids too.
  • Hoverfly (syrphid) larvae. Small legless maggots among the aphids. The adults are the bee-striped flies that hover at flowers.
  • Lacewing larvae. A single green lacewing larva has been recorded eating 100 to 600 aphids.
  • Diseased aphids. In humid weather a fungus kills whole colonies; the bodies turn reddish or brown, fuzzy and shriveled.

Predators and parasites build up only after the aphids do, so there is always a lag. That is why broad-spectrum sprays backfire. Products that leave a residue for a week or longer, such as permethrin, bifenthrin, malathion and carbaryl, kill the natural enemies too, and Minnesota warns that this can make aphid problems worse: the aphids, which fly in and breed in days, recover first.

Go easy on nitrogen. High nitrogen favors aphid reproduction. Feed in small amounts through the season or use slow-release sources, and base it on a soil test.

Controls

  1. Water. A strong stream from the hose knocks aphids off sturdy plants, and most cannot climb back. Spray early in the day so the leaves dry, hit the undersides, and repeat when they build again.
  2. Prune or pinch. Cut off curled tips and the worst shoots, and pull out the odd plant that is covered.
  3. Insecticidal soap or horticultural oil. Both kill by smothering and only kill the aphids they wet, so spray the undersides of leaves thoroughly and expect to repeat. They leave no residue to protect the plant afterward, and once dry they do not harm predators that arrive later. Don't spray drought-stressed plants or when it is above 90°F. Use a product sold as insecticidal soap; home-made dish-soap mixes can burn leaves. Neither reaches aphids inside curled leaves or works well through the wax of woolly aphids.
  4. Neem. Azadirachtin, the active ingredient in neem extracts, discourages feeding and kills slowly; neem oil also works as an oil. UMass found azadirachtin, oil and soap together controlled cabbage aphids better than any one alone.
  5. Row cover or netting. Fine insect mesh of about 0.8 mm keeps aphids off if it goes on at planting. Check under it: aphids that get inside multiply with no predators to stop them. See row covers and insect netting.
  6. Stronger insecticides. Pyrethrins kill on contact and little more. Avoid the long-residual products named above. Systemic insecticides such as imidacloprid and dinotefuran move through the sap of the whole plant and are very toxic to pollinators; do not use them on plants that bees visit. Whatever you use, the crop must be on the label, and spray in the evening, never on open flowers.

Bought lady beetles are a poor answer: about 95 percent fly away within two days. See buying beneficial insects.

When to do nothing

Leave them alone when the plant is established and still growing, when you can see mummies or predator larvae in the colony, when they are on a tree or large shrub, and when hot weather is about to arrive. A few aphids are also what keeps lady beetles and lacewings in the garden.

Cabbage aphids on fall brassicas

Gray, waxy colonies packed into Brussels sprouts, kale hearts and broccoli heads are cabbage aphids, and once they are inside a sprout they are very hard to wash out. This is the one aphid worth scouting for:

  • Check plants weekly from before the sprouts or heads form. Commercial growers act when more than 10 percent of plants have any aphids.
  • Pull out the first heavily infested plants. Colonies start in patches.
  • Spray soap and oil while colonies are small and still on open leaves, with thorough coverage underneath.
  • The eggs overwinter on brassica leaves left standing and hatch around April. Pull old kale, collard and sprout plants and bury or till them in before then.
  • Flowers help only so much. In a 2018 UMass trial beside Brussels sprouts, sweet alyssum drew by far the most aphid-eating hoverflies, followed by dill and cilantro, but the trial counted insects on the flowers, not aphids on the crop, so it does not show that the flowers lower aphid numbers.

Oleander aphids on milkweed

The bright yellow aphids that crowd milkweed stems in summer are oleander aphids. They feed on the milkweed, not on monarchs, and the Monarch Joint Venture says they are a problem for monarchs only at extremely high densities.

Do not use insecticides on milkweed. Purdue's advice is that chemical control is likely to do more harm to monarch caterpillars than the aphids do, and that lady beetles and parasitic wasps usually manage the aphids if left to it. If a plant is smothered, check it first for monarch eggs and caterpillars, then crush the aphids with your fingers and rinse the stem with water. Purdue allows insecticidal soap for severe cases, but soap kills what it wets, caterpillars included, so use it only on stems you have checked. See native milkweeds for monarchs, swamp milkweed and butterfly weed.

For other pests and how to tell them apart, see garden pests.

Sources