Tomato Hornworm
The tomato hornworm (Manduca quinquemaculata) is a big green caterpillar that can strip the leaves off a tomato plant in a few days and chew holes in the green fruit. Despite growing to about 4 inches long, it is hard to see because it matches the foliage so well. Its close relative, the tobacco hornworm (Manduca sexta), does the same damage and is the more common of the two in the South. Both feed on tomato, pepper, eggplant, potato, tobacco and nightshade-family weeds.
Identification
| Tomato hornworm | Tobacco hornworm | |
|---|---|---|
| Side markings | Eight white V-shaped marks on each side | Seven diagonal white stripes edged in black |
| Horn on the tail | Dark blue to black | Red or reddish |
| Adult moth | Five-spotted hawk moth: five pairs of yellow-orange spots on the abdomen | Carolina sphinx: six pairs of spots |
The adults of both are heavy-bodied, grayish-brown hawk moths with a wingspan of 4–5 inches. They fly at dusk and hover at flowers to feed, which is why they are sometimes mistaken for hummingbirds. Eggs are smooth, round, pale green, and laid one at a time on either surface of the leaves.
Signs of damage
- Leaves eaten away, leaving bare stems, often near the top of the plant first.
- Dark green to black droppings (frass) on the leaves or the ground beneath. Droppings are often the first thing you notice; look directly above them.
- Large, chewed-out patches in green fruit.
Hornworms are easiest to find early in the morning or at dusk, when they feed on the outer leaves. They also glow pale green under an ultraviolet flashlight at night.
Life cycle
Hornworms spend the winter as brown pupae a few inches deep in the soil. The moths emerge in late spring or early summer and lay eggs on host plants, which hatch in about a week. The caterpillars feed for three to four weeks, then burrow into the soil to pupate. Northern gardens see one or two generations a year (the University of Minnesota describes a second that starts in midsummer and feeds into early fall), so damage peaks in mid to late summer and you need to keep checking until frost. The South has two or more.
Control
- Hand-pick. In a home garden this is the most effective control. Check plants every few days from midsummer, pull off the caterpillars and drop them in soapy water. Plenty of chicken owners save them as treats.
- Leave parasitized hornworms alone. A hornworm covered in small white cocoons, like grains of rice, has been parasitized by a braconid wasp (Cotesia congregata). It stops feeding and dies, and a new batch of wasps hatches from the cocoons to attack more hornworms. Leave it on the plant.
- Use Bt on small caterpillars. Bacillus thuringiensis var. kurstaki (Bt) is a bacterial insecticide that kills caterpillars that eat treated leaves, and nothing else; it is harmless to people, pets, bees and other insects. It works best on young hornworms, so apply it when you first see damage, and keep it off plants where you want butterfly caterpillars to feed. Spinosad also works; spray it in the evening, because it is toxic to bees until it dries. Insecticidal soap and neem oil do little against hornworms.
- Till after harvest. Turning the soil in fall or early spring where tomatoes grew destroys many of the overwintering pupae. Moths fly in from elsewhere, so this lowers the numbers but does not end the problem. Pull horsenettle, jimsonweed and nightshade nearby, weeds that hornworms also feed on.
- Let natural enemies work. Paper wasps and birds take caterpillars, and lady beetles and lacewings eat eggs and newly hatched larvae. Broad-spectrum insecticides kill these allies too.
Hornworms are one of several tomato problems that show up in late summer; see why tomato plants look bad in mid to late summer and growing tomatoes. The garden pests page covers other common pests.
Sources
- Tomato hornworms in home gardens, University of Minnesota Extension