Leaving Stems and Leaves for Overwintering Insects
Most of the bees, butterflies and beneficial insects in your garden do not leave for the winter. They are in the leaf litter, in the soil and in dead stems, and a thorough fall cleanup removes them. The fix costs nothing: leave perennial stems standing until spring, leave whole leaves on the beds, and keep the tidying for the places where it prevents disease, mainly the vegetable garden.
The part most gardeners miss is what to do in spring. Stems left up all winter and then cut to the ground and hauled away do little for stem-nesting bees. Cut them to stubble 8 to 24 inches tall and leave the stubble for a full year. The reason is below.
Who overwinters where
| Where | Who | In what form |
|---|---|---|
| In the ground | About 70 percent of native bee species: mining bees, squash bees, long-horned bees, many sweat bees | Young bees in small nests, in loose, undisturbed or bare soil |
| Just under the surface, under leaves | Bumblebee queens | Mated queens dig in an inch or two; a layer of leaves insulates them |
| In hollow and pithy stems and in wood | About 30 percent of native bees: small carpenter bees, yellow-faced bees, leafcutter and mason bees | Adults or young inside the stem |
| In leaf litter | Luna moths; swallowtails; great spangled fritillaries; woolly bears; red-banded hairstreaks | Cocoons wrapped in leaves; chrysalises that look like dead leaves; caterpillars; eggs laid on fallen oak leaves |
| On standing stems and at plant bases | Other butterflies and moths; mantises | Chrysalises fastened to stems and twigs; caterpillars at the base of host plants; egg cases on stems |
| Brush piles and loose bark | Mourning cloaks and a few other butterflies; fireflies | Adult butterflies; fireflies sheltering by day |
| Leaf litter, brush and bunch grasses | Lady beetles, ground beetles, lacewings, spiders | Adults and larvae of the predators that eat next year's aphids and slug eggs |
In cold climates the great majority of butterflies and moths pass the winter in or under leaf litter at one life stage or another. Early results from University of Maryland research put a number on it: where leaves were removed, about 67 percent fewer moths and butterflies emerged the next year.
Stems: the two-year cycle
Bees do not nest in a stalk during its first winter. They start nests in stems that have an open end, either broken naturally or cut, and cutting is what opens them. The Xerces Society's sequence runs like this:
- Fall and winter of year one. Leave dead flower stalks standing. Birds eat the seed, and chrysalises and egg cases on the stems stay undisturbed.
- Early spring. Cut the old stalks back, leaving stubble at varying heights from 8 to 24 inches. Do it shortly before the first bees are flying. The cut ends are now open.
- Spring and summer. Female bees find the open stems, stock them with pollen and lay eggs. The larvae grow inside through the season. New growth hides the stubble.
- Fall and winter of year two. The young bees spend the winter inside the stubble.
- Second spring. They emerge and look for newly cut stems. Leave the old stubble where it is; it rots away on its own. Cut this year's dead stalks to stubble next to it, and the cycle continues.
So the stubble you cut this spring has to stay in place until the spring after. A stem plugged at its cut end with mud, leaf pieces or resin has a nest in it.
The tops you cut off can go on the compost pile, or you can bundle them and set them in a sheltered corner, where some will be used too. Unlike a bee house that is reused year after year, stubble breaks down, which limits the build-up of parasites and disease.
Which plants have usable stems
Bees want stems that are hollow or have a soft, pithy center:
- Perennials: coneflowers, bee balm and wild bergamot, goldenrod, asters, black-eyed Susans, native thistles and cup plant. Thin stems suit the smallest bees and thick ones the larger leafcutter bees, which is why a mix of plants and cut heights matters.
- Canes and shrubs: raspberry canes, elderberry, sumac and roses. Small carpenter bees often nest in last year's dead raspberry canes, a few inches from the flowers. When you prune, leave some cut ends at least 4 to 6 inches beyond a node.
Sunflowers, Joe Pye weed, blazing stars and coneflowers are also worth leaving for their seed heads, which goldfinches and other birds work over through winter.
Leaves
- Leave them whole. Rake or blow leaves instead of running the mower over them. Shredding destroys the eggs, caterpillars and cocoons in them, and shredded leaves give less cover.
- Move them to beds. Spread leaves over flower and vegetable beds and pile them around trees, shrubs and perennials. They hold moisture and suppress weeds as shredded wood mulch does (mulching).
- On the lawn, a thin layer is fine. A scattering of leaves feeds the lawn as it breaks down. A couple of inches or more can smother the grass; if you can see little or no grass through the leaves, move them.
- Don't bury small plants. A deep, matted layer can smother the crowns of low perennials and plants such as strawberries. Pull leaves back from those and pile them deeper under shrubs.
- Leave them in spring too. The Xerces Society's point is that the leaves should stay and rot in place. If you do take some off, wait until late spring.
When to cut back in spring
You will often read that you should wait until temperatures have been above 50°F for a week. That is a rule of thumb, not a research finding, and the sources that repeat it do not agree on what it means: University of Illinois Extension says consistently above 50°F overnight, University of Maryland Extension says daytime temperatures above 50°F for several days, and neither cites a study.
The reason no single number works is that insects do not come out all at once. Some cellophane bees are flying in March; some sweat bees do not emerge until late May. Both the Xerces Society and Maryland Extension suggest cues from the garden itself, and they all point later than most people expect:
- If you still need a winter coat, it is too early.
- When the lawn needs regular mowing, most overwintering insects are out.
- When it is safe to set out tomatoes, with nights reliably in the 50s, conditions are right.
- In northern states, mid to late April is the earliest for cutting back, and waiting until the apple trees have finished blooming protects the late emergers.
Later is better, and not clearing at all is better still. The practical version: cut stems to stubble in early spring as described above, keep the cut tops in the yard instead of bagging them, because chrysalises and bees may still be in them, and leave the leaf layer where it lies.
Bare ground, brush and rocks
- Bare soil. Ground-nesting bees need to reach soil. Leave a few sunny patches unmulched, and avoid landscape fabric, plastic and thick wood chips over whole beds. A thin layer of leaves is easier for them to get through than wood mulch. These bees are solitary and not aggressive; each small hole is one female's nest.
- A brush pile in a back corner, built with the largest branches at the bottom. The Xerces Society suggests 2 to 8 feet high and 3 to 10 feet across. Mourning cloak butterflies hibernate in them.
- Logs and rocks. A log left to rot, a loose rock pile or an unmortared stone wall shelters ground beetles and gives bumblebees nest cavities.
What to still clean up
Leaving everything is as mistaken as removing everything. Pests and diseases overwinter in debris too, and they are concentrated in a few places. Iowa State University Extension's list is a good guide:
- The vegetable garden. After frost, remove the leaves, stems and fruit of annual crops. Spent squash vines and old boards shelter squash bugs; vines infested with squash vine borer should be pulled and destroyed before the larvae leave them; tomato debris carries early blight and septoria (tomato diseases). Cut down asparagus ferns once they brown, to remove the asparagus beetles' shelter.
- Fruit. Rake up and discard apple leaves where scab was a problem, pick up dropped fruit, and cut out raspberry canes with anthracnose.
- Diseased perennials. Remove and destroy iris leaves where there were borers, and the tops of bee balm and phlox that were heavily coated with powdery mildew.
- Seedy plants you don't want more of.
Put diseased material in the trash or municipal yard waste, not your own compost, which seldom gets hot enough to kill disease organisms.
This squares with habitat if you treat the garden as zones, as Purdue University's landscape specialists suggest: a tidy zone where you had disease or pests this year, and habitat zones everywhere else. For most gardens that means clean vegetable beds and fruit trees, and flower borders, shrub beds and the ground under trees left alone. See garden pests for the pests that overwinter in crop debris.
Ticks, voles and neighbors
Ticks. Leaf litter is where blacklegged (deer) ticks survive, and the CDC's advice for yards in Lyme disease areas is the opposite of this page: keep grass mown, remove leaf litter, clear tall grass and brush. Both can be true in one yard if you separate the uses. Keep the lawn, paths, play equipment, decks and patios clear and in the sun, away from the woods' edge. Put a 3-foot strip of wood chips or gravel between the lawn and any woods. Keep the leaf layer in beds where people don't sit or play, and check for ticks after working there.
Voles. Voles tunnel under deep mulch and gnaw bark in winter. Penn State Extension advises keeping leaves, prunings and mulch from building up at the base of trees, clearing mulch at least 2 feet back from trunks, and guarding young trees with a cylinder of quarter-inch hardware cloth 18 to 24 inches high, sunk 4 to 6 inches into the soil.
Neighbors. A bed full of dead stalks reads as neglect unless something shows it is deliberate. A mown or edged strip along the front, stems cut to an even stubble in spring, and a small "pollinator habitat" sign do that. So does keeping the brush pile behind a shrub.
More on planting for these insects is in pollinator flowers for fall and building a butterfly garden.
Sources
- Nesting and Overwintering Habitat for Pollinators and Other Beneficial Insects, Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation, 2020
- Save the Stems: How to Create Habitat for Stem-Nesting Bees, Xerces Society
- For pollinators' sake, don't spring into garden cleanup too soon, Xerces Society, revised 2026
- Waiting on spring garden cleanup to support beneficial insects, University of Maryland Extension, 2024
- Managing fallen leaves and fall cleanup, Iowa State University Extension and Outreach
- Preventing Lyme disease, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention