Understanding Garden Netting, Why Quality Matters
I bought garden insect netting to protect my plants from pests, and it worked well at first. But after a few weeks the netting started to fall apart. That's when I realized how much garden netting varies in quality, and that the material makes the difference. Once netting develops holes, it does more harm than good: insects get in, and then the netting traps them inside with your plants.
Here is a link to what I found works.
It comes in different sizes, so measure your bed before ordering, and leave a little extra so you don't come up short.
Here is a short video showing the netting
This video shows the old netting in place and what happened to it.
Why some netting falls apart
Sunlight is the main enemy. Ultraviolet light breaks down plastics that haven't been treated to resist it, and cheap netting made from thin, untreated plastic turns brittle and tears within a season, sometimes within weeks. Heat, wind rubbing the netting against hoops and edges, and being pulled on and off for weeding all add wear.
Better netting is usually knitted rather than woven, from heavier fibers treated with UV stabilizers (often UV-stabilized polyethylene), and holds up for several seasons. When comparing products, look for:
- UV stabilization, stated on the label
- Knitted construction, which resists runs and tears better than loose weaves
- The right mesh size for the job. Bird netting has large openings and stops nothing smaller than a bird. Insect netting needs a fine mesh to keep out small insects such as flea beetles, and the finer the mesh, the more it reduces airflow and light and the more humid it gets underneath, which suits slugs and leaf diseases. As a guide, the Royal Horticultural Society lists butterfly netting (4 to 7 mm) for cabbage white butterflies only, standard insect mesh (1.3 to 1.4 mm) for butterflies, moths, carrot fly and cabbage root fly but not reliably for aphids or flea beetles, fine mesh (0.8 mm) for flea beetles, leaf miner flies and aphids as well, and ultrafine mesh (0.3 to 0.6 mm) for thrips. Row covers and insect netting lists the mesh for each pest and when to cover and uncover each crop.
- Enough width to cover the hoops and reach the ground on both sides with some to spare
One caution about bird netting, the wide black plastic mesh sold for berries and fruit trees: loose or sagging, or left in a heap on the ground, it tangles and kills songbirds and snakes. If you use it, stretch it taut over a frame, pin the edges down, check it daily and take it down after harvest. Stiff wire mesh such as chicken wire is the safer choice where it will do the job.
Installing netting so it works
- Cover at planting time. Netting keeps insects out; it doesn't get rid of the ones already there.
- Use hoops. Support the netting on wire or PVC hoops so it doesn't rest on the leaves. Insects can feed or lay eggs through netting that touches the plants.
- Seal the edges. Bury the edges or weigh them down along their whole length with boards, sandbags or soil. Gaps at ground level let in insects, and slugs and cutworms come up from below anyway.
- Rotate crops. Pests that spend the winter in the soil, such as flea beetles, will emerge under the netting if you cover the same crop in the same bed as last year.
- Know which crops can stay covered. Cabbage, kale, broccoli, greens, carrots and potatoes don't need pollinators and can stay covered all season. Squash, cucumbers and melons need bees, so uncover them when they start flowering, or hand-pollinate.
- Check under it. Lift the netting once a week to look for pests, weeds and watering needs.
With a mesh fine enough for the pest, netting works especially well against flea beetles, cabbage worms, Japanese beetles and leafhoppers. For other pests and controls, see garden pests and the video on preventing pest damage without chemicals.
Sources
- Insect-proof mesh, Royal Horticultural Society
- Coexisting with snakes: What kinds of gardening mesh are safe for snakes?, University of Illinois Extension, 2021
