Powdery Mildew
Powdery mildew is the white, flour-like coating that shows up on squash, zinnias, phlox, bee balm, peas, lilacs and thousands of other plants, usually from midsummer on. On most ornamentals and on vegetables near the end of their season it is a cosmetic problem you can ignore. On squash, pumpkins and melons that catch it early, it costs yield, flavor and storage life and is worth heading off.
Two facts change how you deal with it. It is the one common leaf disease that does not need wet leaves, so careful watering will not prevent it. And every spray a gardener can buy protects healthy leaf tissue; none of them cures a leaf that is already white. Resistant varieties, sun and spacing do most of the work.
What it is
Powdery mildew is caused by hundreds of related fungi that between them infect more than 10,000 plant species. Each one sticks to its own hosts. The fungus on squash and cucumbers (mainly Podosphaera xanthii) does not infect plants outside the squash family, and the mildews on lilac, garden phlox, roses and peas do not move to your squash. Mildew on the lilac is not the source of the mildew on the zucchini.
The fungi are obligate parasites: they grow only on living plant tissue. Most of the fungus sits on the leaf surface and feeds through pegs it sends into the outer cells.
How to recognize it
- White to gray powdery spots, usually on the upper side of the leaf. On squash they appear on both sides and on leaf stalks and stems.
- It starts on older, lower, shaded leaves. On squash it usually appears only after the plants begin setting fruit.
- Spots spread and merge until the leaf is coated, then the leaf yellows, browns and dries.
- Late in the season you may see pinhead-sized dark specks in the white growth. These are the fungus's resting structures.
Downy mildew is a different disease with different weather needs: angular yellow patches on top of the leaf and gray or purple fuzz underneath.
The biology gardeners get wrong
Most leaf diseases need a film of water on the leaf to infect. Powdery mildew is the reverse:
- The spores germinate without free water. All powdery mildews can infect a dry leaf, and extended wetness inhibits germination and kills the spores of some species. Rain is unfavorable for the squash mildew.
- It wants humid air, not wet leaves. High humidity helps infection, but the squash mildew can infect at relative humidity as low as 50 percent. Cool, humid nights build spores and warm, dry days spread them.
- Mild temperatures. Development is fastest at about 68 to 80°F and possible from about 50 to 90°F. The fungi are sensitive to heat above 90°F and to direct sun.
- Shade and crowding. It is worst on shaded plants, in dense growth and where air does not move.
So keeping leaves dry does not prevent powdery mildew, and overhead watering does not cause it. Water at the base anyway, because wet leaves bring on the diseases that do need them, such as downy mildew, anthracnose and the tomato leaf spots.
The spores travel long distances on wind. The squash mildew is thought to move north each summer from crops in the South, which is why rotation and fall clean-up do little against it. Other mildews overwinter on the plant itself, in buds of woody plants or as resting structures on old leaves and stems.
How much it matters
On lilacs, phlox, bee balm, zinnias and most trees and shrubs, extension pathologists rate it as a cosmetic problem that needs no treatment unless it is severe enough to reduce growth and flowering. The same goes for a squash or pea planting that turns white in its last few weeks.
It matters when it arrives early on a crop that still has fruit to ripen. On squash, pumpkins and melons, leaves that die early mean fewer and smaller fruit, sunscald, fruit that ripens early or incompletely, poor keeping quality in winter squash, low sugar and poor flavor in melons, and shriveled handles on pumpkins.
Resistant varieties
This is the control that works best. Catalogs mark it "PM" or "PMR". Resistant squash and pumpkins still get some mildew, later and lighter. Resistance is standard in modern cucumber varieties, and many melons have it.
| Plant | Varieties listed or trialed as resistant |
|---|---|
| Zucchini and summer squash | 'Dunja', 'Desert', 'Payroll', 'Emerald Delight', 'Spineless Perfection', 'Success PM' (yellow straightneck) |
| Winter squash | acorn 'Honey Bear', 'Table Star', 'Sweet REBA'; butternut 'Metro PMR', 'JWS 6823'; 'Bush Delicata' |
| Pumpkin | 'Magic Lantern', 'Gladiator' |
| Cucumber | 'Marketmore 76', 'Diva', 'General Lee', 'Corinto' |
| Melon | 'Athena', 'Ambrosia', 'Sugar Cube', 'Hannah's Choice' |
| Peas | 'Green Arrow', 'Cascadia', 'Sugar Ann', 'Super Sugar Snap', 'Oregon Sugar Pod II', 'Oregon Giant' |
| Zinnia | Profusion and Zahara series; the Oklahoma series is less susceptible than other tall cutting types |
| Garden phlox | 'Jeana' and 'David' (excellent resistance in Mt. Cuba Center's 2015 to 2017 trial; 'David' still had frequent, very mild infections), 'Glamour Girl' (good) |
| Bee balm | 'Marshall's Delight', 'Raspberry Wine', 'Colrain Red', 'Violet Queen' (Chicago Botanic Garden's four-year trial) |
Resistance is not immunity. In the Chicago bee balm trial even the most resistant varieties showed mildew in the worst year, and plant pathologists report that the squash mildew is slowly adapting to the resistance in squash and pumpkins.
Sun, spacing and nitrogen
- Plant susceptible plants in full sun.
- Give them their full spacing (zucchini, zinnias, peas) and thin crowded clumps of phlox and bee balm so air moves through.
- Do not overfeed with nitrogen. It produces soft new growth and dense shade, which the fungus prefers. Fertilize by soil test.
- Sow a second planting of summer squash away from the first; old plants are a source of spores for young ones.
What sprays do
Every product below works by contact and protects healthy tissue. It has to be on both sides of the leaf before or just as infection starts, and be repeated every 7 to 10 days while the weather favors mildew. Farm guidelines start when 1 older leaf in 50 shows a spot; in a garden that means the day you see the first spots. The label is the rule for rates, crops and days to harvest.
| Product | What trials show | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Sulfur | The most effective organic product in Cornell's field trials on squash and pumpkin, and one of the least expensive. Control on the underside of leaves was poor to variable. | Works only if applied before symptoms spread. Do not apply near or above 90°F (some labels say 85°F). Damages melons and some squash varieties, so test a few leaves first. |
| Horticultural and plant oils, including neem | Very effective on the upper leaf surface in the same trials, with some effect underneath. Oils are the only products here with some ability to stop mild, existing infections. | Never above 90°F or on drought-stressed plants. Never within two weeks of a sulfur spray; the combination burns leaves. Neem also harms insects, so spray in the evening and keep it off open flowers. |
| Potassium bicarbonate | Moderate to good on the upper surface, slight underneath. | Contact only; washes off. |
| Biological fungicides (Bacillus products) | Ineffective to moderate; less effective than sulfur or oil. | Preventive only. |
| Milk | In greenhouse trials on zucchini, 5 to 50 percent milk in water sprayed once or twice a week reduced mildew, and the stronger mixes did better than the two fungicides tested. Field results have been mixed, and it works better before infection than after. | Smells as it breaks down and grows harmless but unsightly molds on the leaf. No published trials on roses or other ornamentals. |
| Baking soda | Does not kill the fungus; it stops spores germinating only while the leaf surface stays alkaline, and rain washes it off. Field results range from good to poor with no pattern. It has worked better mixed with horticultural oil. | A 1 percent solution has caused severe leaf damage. Potassium bicarbonate does the same job with less risk. |
Home-made mixes with dish soap can burn leaves, and none of these sprays reaches the fungus well on the underside of a big squash leaf, which is where it develops best.
Why spraying a white plant in September is pointless
No spray clears a leaf that is already coated, so spraying a fully white plant treats tissue that is past saving. By then the plant has few weeks left and few new leaves to protect, and on ornamentals the damage is to looks only. Cut bee balm to the ground after flowering if the foliage bothers you, pull finished squash vines, and put the effort into a resistant variety and a sunnier, roomier spot next year.
Composting infected leaves
Extension sources disagree. Penn State, Washington State and Illinois advise against composting mildewed plants, because home piles rarely get hot enough to kill spores. Oregon State's plant pathologist says composting them is no problem at all, because the fungus survives only on a living host and dies with the plant in the pile.
The biology supports a middle course. The powdery summer spores live only about a week away from a living leaf, so they do not survive composting. The dark resting structures formed late in the season can survive winter on dead leaves, and a cool, slow pile may not kill them. Compost mildewed squash vines and annuals freely, since that mildew blows in each year regardless. For perennials that get mildew every year, such as phlox, bee balm and peonies, clear the old stems and leaves in fall and keep them out of a cold pile. See composting for how to run a pile hot.
Sources
- Cucurbit Powdery Mildew, Cornell University, 2024
- Powdery Mildew on Vegetables (Pest Notes 7406), University of California Statewide IPM Program, 2008
- Organic disease management: Powdery mildew in cucurbit crops, Cornell University Long Island Vegetable Health
- Disease-resistant cucurbit varieties, Cornell University
- Monarda and Powdery Mildew Resistance (Plant Evaluation Notes 12), Chicago Botanic Garden, 1998
- The Myth of Milk and Roses and Baking soda: will fungi fail and roses rejoice?, Linda Chalker-Scott, Washington State University, 2008 and 2009