Invasive Garden Plants and What to Grow Instead

Some of the most familiar landscape plants, including Japanese barberry, burning bush, Bradford pear and English ivy, don't stay in the yard. Birds carry their seed into woods and wetlands, where they crowd out the native plants that insects and birds depend on. Several are now illegal to sell in some states.

Whether a plant is invasive depends on where you live, so check your own state's list before you buy a shrub, tree, vine or ground cover. If the plant is on it, there is nearly always a native that does the same job. The table below pairs the common offenders with replacements.

What "invasive" means

The federal definition has two parts: the species is not native to the ecosystem in question, and its introduction causes or is likely to cause economic or environmental harm or harm to human health. Both parts are needed.

  • Non-native is not the same as invasive. Tomatoes, lettuce, tulips and peonies are non-native and stay where they are put.
  • Aggressive is not the same as invasive. Mint overruns a bed, and native trumpet vine and Virginia creeper can overrun a fence, but none of them is degrading natural areas. They are a nuisance to you, not to the woods.
  • It is regional. Lantana is a harmless annual where frost kills it and a serious invader in Florida. Butterfly bush is a regulated noxious weed in Oregon and Washington.

How to check your state

Three kinds of list exist, and they are not the same thing:

  1. State law. A noxious weed or prohibited plant list, usually kept by the department of agriculture or natural resources. Plants on it may not be sold, and sometimes may not be planted. New York, for example, sorts plants into "prohibited" (no sale, purchase, transport or propagation) and "regulated" (legal to sell, with a label reading "Invasive Species - Harmful to the Environment", but not to release into natural areas).
  2. State invasive plant council lists. These rank plants by the harm they do, whether or not the law has caught up. Many plants on council lists are still for sale.
  3. Maps. The Invasive Plant Atlas of the United States shows where each species has been reported.

Your county extension office can tell you which apply. Search for your state's name with "invasive plant list" and "noxious weed list".

Common garden plants that are listed, and replacements

"Listed" below names only the places confirmed from a state or extension page; most of these plants are listed in more states than the ones given.

Plant Where it is listed How it spreads Grow instead
Butterfly bush (Buddleja davidii) Noxious weed in Oregon and Washington, which allow only approved "seedless" cultivars Wind-blown seed, onto riverbanks and gravel bars Buttonbush, summersweet, swamp milkweed, Joe Pye weed, garden phlox 'Jeana'
Japanese barberry (Berberis thunbergii) Prohibited in New York; a noxious weed in Pennsylvania, illegal to sell or plant except exempt sterile varieties Birds spread the berries into woods; branches root where they touch the ground; deer don't eat it Ninebark, Virginia sweetspire, inkberry or winterberry holly, New Jersey tea
Burning bush (Euonymus alatus) Regulated in New York; on North Carolina's invasive plant council list Birds and deer eat the berries and carry the seed into woodland edges For red fall color: chokeberry, fothergilla, highbush blueberry, Virginia sweetspire
Callery pear, 'Bradford' and the rest (Pyrus calleryana) Illegal to sell in Ohio since January 7, 2023; on South Carolina's invasive plant pest list Birds eat the fruit; seedlings form thorny thickets along roads and field edges Serviceberry, redbud, fringetree, flowering dogwood
Japanese honeysuckle (Lonicera japonica) Prohibited in New York and Ohio Runners, rhizomes and bird-carried seed; smothers shrubs and young trees Coral honeysuckle, crossvine, Carolina jessamine
English ivy (Hedera helix) Noxious weed in Washington, where four common cultivars may not be sold Creeping stems; vines that climb and mature set berries and seed Wild ginger, native sedges, Allegheny pachysandra; more in supporting plants
Periwinkle (Vinca minor) North Carolina's invasive plant council list Stems root at the nodes into mats that spread out of the garden Foamflower, green-and-gold, woodland phlox, native ferns
Chinese wisteria (Wisteria sinensis) Invasive in North Carolina Rampant growth that forms dense thickets American wisteria (Wisteria frutescens)
Purple loosestrife (Lythrum salicaria) Prohibited in Minnesota, New York and Ohio One plant can make up to 2.7 million seeds a year; takes over wetlands Blazing star, swamp milkweed, Joe Pye weed, great blue lobelia, obedient plant
Norway maple (Acer platanoides) Regulated in New York; considered invasive in several northeastern states Seeds itself freely, cultivars included, and casts shade little else grows under Red maple, sugar maple, American basswood
Privet (Ligustrum) Border privet prohibited in New York; common privet barred from sale in Ohio from 2026; Chinese privet invasive across the South Birds spread the berries; suckers form thickets Inkberry holly, northern bayberry, arrowwood viburnum
Nandina, heavenly bamboo (Nandina domestica) North Carolina's invasive plant council list Birds and small mammals eat the fruit Winterberry, American beautyberry, native viburnums
Chinese silvergrass (Miscanthus sinensis) Regulated in New York; North Carolina's council list Wind-blown seed and a tough mass of rhizomes; also highly flammable Switchgrass, little bluestem, Indiangrass, big bluestem
Japanese knotweed (Reynoutria japonica) Prohibited in New York and Ohio Rhizome fragments in moved soil and floodwater; cut stems root Nothing to replace: no one should plant it
Running bamboo (golden and yellow groove bamboo, Phyllostachys) Both prohibited in New York Rhizomes; barriers often fail A mixed screen of native shrubs such as viburnums, bayberry and shrub dogwoods
Lantana (Lantana camara) Invasive in Florida and Hawaii; escaped in Texas and other Gulf states Birds spread the seed Sterile cultivars such as the 'Bloomify' series, or a native lantana
Montbretia (Crocosmia × crocosmiiflora) Rated invasive (Limited) on the California coast and around San Francisco Bay Corms and seed, into coastal scrub and roadsides Crocosmia 'Lucifer', with the seed pods removed
Bigleaf lupine (Lupinus polyphyllus) and its garden hybrids Naturalized across New England and watched as potentially invasive Heavy seeding; it also crosses with native wild lupine Wild lupine (Lupinus perennis) on sandy soil in the East; see lupine

Three more plants on this site need a note. Tropical milkweed is not on invasive lists, but where it survives winter it harms the monarchs it is planted for; see native milkweeds for monarchs. Chinese lantern and mint are bed thugs: they run by rhizomes through a border and belong in a container, but they are a garden problem, not a threat to natural areas.

Barberry and ticks

Japanese barberry has a cost beyond the woods. Researchers at the Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station sampled blacklegged (deer) ticks for up to ten years in stands with barberry, stands where it had been cleared, and stands without it. Intact barberry held 458 adult ticks infected with the Lyme disease bacterium per hectare, about 185 per acre. Areas without barberry held 140 per hectare, about 57 per acre. The dense, low shrubs keep the air under them humid, and ticks, which die when they dry out, survive there.

Clearing the barberry brought infected ticks down close to the no-barberry level, and the numbers climbed again as the barberry grew back. The authors recommend controlling it at least every five years.

Nandina berries and birds

Nandina's red berries hang on through winter, and all parts of the plant contain compounds that release cyanide. In April 2009, cedar waxwings were found dead in a yard in Thomas County, Georgia. University of Georgia veterinary pathologists examined five; their digestive tracts held only nandina berries, and the damage matched cyanide poisoning. Waxwings are at risk because they feed in flocks and gorge on fruit. If you keep nandina, cut off the berry clusters, or grow a non-fruiting cultivar such as 'Fire Power' or 'Gulf Stream'.

What "sterile" has meant in practice

The Callery pear is the lesson. 'Bradford' was sold as a sterile tree, and a 'Bradford' on its own sets almost no fruit, because Callery pears cannot pollinate themselves. Then other cultivars were planted on the same streets. Two different cultivars pollinate each other, the trees fruit heavily, birds eat the fruit, and the seedlings are wild, thorny pears. Sterile only meant sterile alone.

Read cultivar claims with that in mind:

  • "Seedless" butterfly bush means low fertility, not none: the standard Oregon and Washington use is less than 2 percent viable seed. Deadhead it anyway.
  • Barberry, nandina and rose of Sharon are sold in sterile or nearly sterile forms. University of Maryland Extension points out that such plants still flower, and their pollen can fertilize escaped plants nearby, so they are not a complete answer.
  • Chinese silvergrass cultivars differ; a few set little or no seed.
  • A state exemption is the best evidence. Pennsylvania, Oregon and Washington exempt specific tested cultivars from their bans. A plant tag is not a test.

Where a native alternative will do the job, it is the surer choice.

If you already have one

A sale ban does not usually oblige you to remove a plant that is already in your yard; New York's rule says so directly. Noxious weed laws can be different, and some states require landowners to control the weeds on that list, so check. Either way, removing the plant is one of the more useful things you can do, most of all if you live next to woods, a stream or a wetland.

  • Stop the seed first. Until you can remove the plant, cut off flowers or fruit before the seed ripens: deadhead butterfly bush, clip nandina berries, and don't let ivy climb, because it is the vines that have climbed and matured that set seed.
  • Small plants pull out by hand when the soil is moist. Get the roots.
  • Shrubs and trees such as barberry and Callery pear resprout from the stump when they are only cut. Penn State Extension's advice is to cut and then treat the fresh stump, or the regrowth, with an herbicide labeled for that use. Follow the label.
  • Knotweed and running bamboo are in a different class. Cutting alone does not control knotweed, and control takes at least two seasons. Ask your extension office for a plan before you start, and never move soil that holds the rhizomes.
  • Don't give it away. Don't pass divisions or seedlings of a listed plant to other gardeners.

Disposal. Seeds and root pieces survive a home compost pile, which seldom gets hot enough to kill them. Let pulled plants dry out and die on a tarp or pavement, where they can't root, then bag them for the trash, or ask your yard-waste service whether it accepts invasive plants. Don't dump prunings at the edge of the woods, and don't burn them.

For choosing plants in the first place, see home garden design and growing flowering plants.

Sources