Native Milkweeds for Monarchs

Monarch caterpillars eat milkweed and nothing else, so a monarch garden starts with milkweed that is native to your region. Plant two or three species suited to your soil. Where they are native, swamp milkweed and common milkweed are the ones monarchs lay the most eggs on. Skip tropical milkweed, buy plants that were not treated with systemic insecticides, and leave the aphids alone.

Milkweed is half the job. Adult monarchs need nectar, most of all in late summer and fall when they are flying south, so plant fall flowers too.

Why milkweed

Female monarchs lay their eggs only on milkweeds (Asclepias) and a few close relatives, and the caterpillars can develop on nothing else. Milkweeds contain cardenolides, bitter heart poisons that are toxic to most animals. Monarch caterpillars take them up and store them in their own bodies. The Xerces Society cites the loss of milkweed across the breeding range as a significant factor in the decline of the monarchs counted at the overwintering sites in Mexico and California.

Which milkweed to plant

The Monarch Joint Venture divides the country into milkweed regions and lists species for each that monarchs are known to use and that are easy to establish. Its Northeast region takes in the Midwest as well.

Milkweed Region Site Notes
Common milkweed (Asclepias syriaca) Northeast and Midwest; parts of the Southeast Full sun, well-drained soil; zones 3–9 3 to 5 feet, fragrant. Sends up shoots from its roots several feet from the parent, so it suits a meadow or a rough corner, not a small bed.
Swamp milkweed (A. incarnata) Northeast and Midwest; parts of the Southeast Sun; moist soil, clay included Stays in a clump. The easiest milkweed to fit into a garden.
Butterfly weed (A. tuberosa) Northeast, Midwest, Southeast, Arizona Sun; dry, well-drained soil Orange flowers, deep taproot, clump-forming. Monarchs lay fewer eggs on it, but it stays in good condition late in the season.
Whorled milkweed (A. verticillata) Northeast, Midwest, Southeast Sun; dry to average soil; zones 4–9 1 to 2½ feet. Spreads by rhizomes and seed.
Poke milkweed (A. exaltata) Northeast and Midwest woodlands, not the Plains states Part shade; moist soil rich in organic matter; zones 3–7 The milkweed for a woodland edge.
Purple milkweed (A. purpurascens) Northeast and Midwest Sun to part shade; zones 3–8 2 to 3 feet. Hard to find for sale. NC State warns it can spread by seed and rhizomes.
Showy milkweed (A. speciosa) West and California Sun; prairies and open ground The Iowa State researchers recommend it where common milkweed does not grow.
Narrowleaf milkweed (A. fascicularis) California and the West, except Colorado, Utah, New Mexico and Arizona Sun; dry sites One of California's later-season milkweeds.
Green antelopehorn (A. viridis) and antelopehorns (A. asperula) South Central; antelopehorns also in Arizona Sun; dry prairie for the first, desert and sandy soil for the second The Monarch Joint Venture's picks for Texas and Oklahoma.
Aquatic milkweed (A. perennis) Southeast Wet soil For ground that stays wet.

California has early species as well (woollypod, California and heartleaf milkweed) that come up in March and April, ahead of narrowleaf and showy milkweed; the Xerces Society recommends planting some of each.

For a list that is specific to your state, use the Xerces Society's regional milkweed guides. A few places have no native milkweed at all: western Washington, northwestern Oregon, Alaska and Hawaii. There, Xerces advises planting native nectar flowers instead of milkweed.

Near the California coast, don't plant milkweed. Monarchs spend the winter in groves along the coast, where milkweed does not grow naturally, and milkweed there can disrupt their overwintering. The Xerces Society's guidance is no milkweed within 5 miles of the coast north of Santa Barbara and within 1 mile of the coast south of it.

Which species monarchs prefer

Iowa State University and USDA researchers planted nine milkweeds native to the Midwest in field plots and counted monarch eggs for three years. Swamp milkweed and common milkweed had the most eggs in every year, with no significant difference between the two. Butterfly weed and whorled milkweed got significantly fewer, and poke milkweed fewer still.

Caterpillars survived and pupated on all nine, so a less-favored milkweed is not wasted. The researchers recommend planting several species with different site needs, so that some milkweed is in good condition whatever the weather does. A reasonable garden mix is swamp milkweed where the soil holds moisture, butterfly weed where it is dry, and common milkweed if you have room for it to run.

Skip tropical milkweed

Tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica), with red and yellow flowers, is the milkweed most garden centers sell because it is easy to grow and blooms all summer. It is native from Mexico southward, not to the United States.

Native milkweeds die back in fall. Tropical milkweed keeps growing wherever frost doesn't kill it, and that causes two problems:

  • Parasite build-up. Monarchs infected with the protozoan parasite OE (Ophryocystis elektroscirrha) shed spores onto the leaves, and caterpillars swallow them as they feed. On leaves that never die back, spores accumulate from one generation to the next. In Project Monarch Health sampling, 49 percent of winter-breeding monarchs were infected, against 9 percent of migrating monarchs sampled in Mexico and 15 percent in the northern US and Canada. Badly infected butterflies may fail to emerge; mildly infected ones live shorter lives and fly poorly.
  • Winter breeding. Along the Gulf Coast, in Florida and in California, milkweed that is green in fall and winter lets monarchs keep breeding when they would otherwise migrate.

The Xerces Society advises against planting tropical milkweed at all, and the Monarch Joint Venture advises replacing it with native species. If you keep it where it does not freeze to the ground, cut it to about 6 inches from October through February, and cut the regrowth every few weeks. (South of Orlando, Florida, where a non-migratory monarch population has long lived, the Monarch Joint Venture says the cut-back advice does not apply, though it still encourages native milkweed there.) Where frost kills it every fall, the parasite risk is smaller. Butterfly weed gives you the same bright color and is native over most of the East.

Buying plants and seed

  • Ask about insecticides. Nursery plants treated with systemic insecticides, the neonicotinoids (imidacloprid, dinotefuran, clothianidin, thiamethoxam), carry the insecticide in their leaves and can kill the caterpillars that eat them. You can't tell by looking. Ask before you buy; a native plant nursery that grows its own stock can answer.
  • Buy local. The Monarch Joint Venture asks gardeners to find plants grown as close as possible to where they will be planted, from the closest possible seed source. The Xerces Society's Milkweed Seed Finder helps you find local vendors of native seed and plants.

Growing milkweed from seed

Milkweed seed needs a cold, moist period before it will sprout.

  • Fall sowing is the simplest: sow outdoors in late fall and let winter do it.
  • Refrigerator. Mix the seed with damp sand or fold it in a moist paper towel and keep it in the refrigerator for about four weeks, then sow. Seedlings are ready to plant out about eight weeks later, so start about three months before your planting date, after the last frost (find your frost dates).

Water seedlings through their first summer. Plant butterfly weed where it is to stay, because its taproot does not survive moving. Swamp milkweed and butterfly weed come up late in spring, so mark the spot. Butterfly weed usually takes two or three years to flower from seed.

Unwanted shoots of common milkweed pull out by hand. The Xerces Society notes that no milkweed is listed as a noxious weed and that milkweeds are unlikely to become an unmanageable problem in a home garden.

What else lives on milkweed

A milkweed patch draws its own set of insects. None of them calls for a spray, and anything that kills them kills monarch eggs and caterpillars too.

  • Oleander aphids. Bright yellow-orange, clustered on stems and pods in midsummer. They rarely hurt an established plant. If you want them off, check for monarch eggs and small caterpillars first, then squash them or knock them off with the hose. Lady beetles, hoverfly larvae, lacewing larvae and tiny parasitic wasps find them on their own; buying lady beetles to release is not recommended. See aphids.
  • Milkweed bugs. Orange and black, on the pods. They feed on the seeds, which matters only if you want to save seed.
  • Milkweed tussock moth caterpillars. They eat the leaves late in the season and do little lasting damage.
  • Milkweed beetles and weevils. Milkweed longhorn beetles, leaf beetles and a stem weevil also feed on the plants. Leave them.

Insecticidal soap and neem are insecticides here as well. So are the yard sprays and foggers sold for mosquitoes.

Nectar for the trip south

Each fall monarchs fly to their overwintering sites in Mexico and on the California coast, and they need nectar the whole way. Plant late bloomers for them: goldenrod, asters, Joe Pye weed and the others in pollinator flowers for fall. For layout and other host plants, see building a butterfly garden.

Don't raise them by the dozen

Raising a caterpillar or two indoors to watch is fine. Raising many for release is not conservation: crowded containers spread OE, captive-reared monarchs migrate less successfully than wild ones, and no study shows that releases increase the population. The Xerces Society's limit is ten a year per household, collected locally, never bought or shipped.

Milkweed is poisonous

Cardenolides make every part of the plant poisonous to people, pets and livestock. The ASPCA lists milkweed as toxic to dogs, cats and horses. The plants are bitter and animals seldom eat much, but sheep and goats are at real risk: for the most toxic species the Xerces Society gives a lethal dose of less than 1 percent of the animal's body weight in fresh plant. Keep milkweed out of pastures and hayfields.

The sap irritates skin and is a real hazard to eyes. Wear gloves when you cut plants back, wash your hands before touching your face, and if sap gets in an eye, rinse it with water for 10 to 15 minutes and get medical care if it still hurts. More in poisonous garden plants.

Sources