Why Vegetables Bolt

Bolting is a vegetable sending up a flower stalk before you have harvested it. Once a plant makes that switch, it moves its stored food into the stalk and seeds: lettuce and spinach turn bitter, roots and bulbs stop swelling, and leeks and onions grow a tough core. You cannot reverse it. Everything useful happens beforehand.

Heat gets the blame because the stalk appears in warm weather, but the signal was often given weeks earlier. There are three different triggers, and each crop answers to its own. Knowing which one applies tells you whether to plant later, plant earlier, buy smaller transplants, or change variety.

The three triggers

Trigger Crops What the research and extension services report
Cold on young plants (vernalization). Biennials and many cabbage-family crops read a long chill as winter and flower when warmth returns. Onions from sets and large transplants, leeks, celery, beets, chard, carrots, cabbage, broccoli and cauliflower (which "button"), kohlrabi, bok choy, turnips, mustard Onions and other alliums: 40°F to 50°F for one to two months (Wisconsin); for onions about three to four weeks below 50°F once the plant has roughly five leaves (Lincoln University, Missouri). Cabbage and broccoli: ten or more days in a row between 35°F and 50°F (Clemson). Kohlrabi and bok choy: a late frost or more than a week of nights below 50°F (Minnesota). Celery: ten days or more below 55°F. Carrots need far more, six to eight weeks near 36°F to 41°F (USDA), so spring carrots rarely bolt.
Lengthening days. Long-day annuals flower when days pass a set length, whatever you do. Spinach (about 14 hours), lettuce (with heat), some radishes, cilantro, and the mustard family once it has been chilled: arugula, mustard greens, Asian greens, turnips Spinach is the pure case; see growing spinach. Varieties differ in their threshold, and Dutch research found that longer days go on speeding up bolting, leveling off at around 16 hours in some varieties. In the mustard family, cold comes first and lengthening days then bring the stalk up.
Heat and stress. These rarely start bolting in a biennial, but they speed up a plant that has already been triggered. Lettuce, spinach, cilantro, dill, fennel, bok choy, and any crop already triggered Lettuce is the exception that heat alone can trigger. Dill sends up its stalk when the weather turns hot or dry. Dry soil pushes cauliflower, arugula and spinach to flower sooner, and cabbage-family transplants held too long in their pots tend to button.

Two details in the cold row decide most cases.

Plant size matters as much as temperature. Very young seedlings cannot register cold. Beets, carrots and onions can be triggered only after they pass a juvenile size, and with cabbage-family transplants, the larger the plant when the cold arrives, the more of them bolt. That is why an overgrown transplant set out early is the one that fails, while a small one beside it does not.

The chill adds up. In onions, cold exposure accumulates, and once the plant has had enough, bolting cannot be avoided. The stalk then appears when the weather warms, and warmth makes it grow faster.

"It got hot" is often the wrong diagnosis

If your onions, celery, kohlrabi or broccoli bolt in June, look back to April. A crop in the first row of the table was almost certainly chilled as a young plant, and the heat only brought the stalk into view. Planting earlier next year "to beat the heat" makes it worse. For spinach, the cause is the calendar: by late spring the days are simply too long. Only for lettuce, cilantro and dill is hot weather itself a main cause.

What you can do

  • Plant in the right window. Planting too early promotes bolting in cabbage and its relatives; planting too late does it in lettuce and spinach. Work from your frost dates with the zone and frost date lookup, and do not set out celery, kohlrabi, bok choy or chard weeks ahead of the dates in their guides.
  • Buy or raise small transplants. Onion seedlings should be about a quarter inch thick, thinner than a pencil, when they go out. Cabbage-family transplants should be stocky, with four to six true leaves and not root-bound. Harden celery by easing off on water, not by chilling it.
  • Sort onion sets. Sets larger than a dime or a nickel, roughly three quarters of an inch, often bolt. Plant those for green onions and keep the small ones for bulbs. See growing onions.
  • Cover young plants in a cold snap. Row covers and low tunnels cut the amount of cold a young plant accumulates.
  • Grow day-length crops into shortening days. Spinach sown in August grows under shortening days and does not bolt before winter. Arugula, mustard, bok choy, cilantro and fennel are all easier as fall crops.
  • Choose slow-bolting varieties for spring. Named examples from trials and extension lists: 'Space' and 'Escalade' spinach, 'Green Magic' broccoli, 'Boltardy' beet, 'Green Wave' mustard, 'Fernleaf' dill, and 'Calypso' cilantro, which bolts about three weeks later than 'Santo'. The lettuce guide lists heat-tolerant lettuces. Slow-bolting means later, not never. Red onions seem to bolt more readily than yellow or white ones, and sets sold as heat-treated have had their flower buds suppressed.
  • Keep plants watered and cool. Even moisture, mulch and afternoon shade delay the stalk in lettuce, cilantro and other heat-triggered crops. They do not help a crop that was triggered by cold or day length. In Alaska trials, wider spacing made no difference to how soon spinach bolted.
  • Sow little and often. A short row of cilantro every two to three weeks, or dill every 10 to 14 days in cool weather, means the next sowing is ready when the last one bolts. See succession planting.

What bolting does to flavor

Lettuce's bitterness comes from compounds called sesquiterpene lactones, mainly lactucin and lactucopicrin. A study of 22 lettuce varieties measured them at the eating stage and again after bolting: lactucin ran from about 2 to 42 micrograms per gram of dried leaf before bolting and 10 to 213 after, and lactucopicrin from about 10 to 345 before and 169 to 3,888 after. The same study found the levels rise with the age of the leaf, which is why old lettuce is bitter even before the stalk shows.

In root and bulb crops the loss is in texture and size. The plant stops filling the root or bulb, the flower stalk runs through the center, and a bolted onion has a thick neck that is hard to cure for storage.

What is still usable

  • Cut the stalk if you like, but it will not reset the plant. Removing an onion's flower stalk helps the bulb only a little. Pull bolted onions and use them right away as green or fresh onions; they do not keep.
  • Lettuce and spinach: harvest the whole planting as soon as the center starts to stretch.
  • Kale, mustard and Asian greens: the young flower shoots, buds and flowers are tender and good to eat, like broccoli raab.
  • Cilantro: let it go. The seeds are coriander, and the flowers draw hoverflies, whose larvae eat aphids, and small parasitic wasps. Dill flowers do the same. See growing cilantro and growing dill.
  • Leeks: take off flower stalks as soon as they form, since flowering makes the center fibrous, and eat those plants first. The tight flower buds are good lightly cooked. See growing leeks.
  • Garlic scapes are a different matter. Hardneck garlic sends up a scape every year as part of normal growth after winter cold; it does not mean anything went wrong. Remove it for a larger bulb and eat it. See garlic scapes and growing garlic.

Sources