Downy Mildew

Downy mildew shows as yellow patches on the top of a leaf, often angular because the leaf veins stop them, with gray, purple or white fuzz directly underneath on damp mornings. It moves fast in cool, wet weather and can strip a cucumber planting or kill a bed of basil or impatiens in a week or two.

It shares a name with powdery mildew and nothing else. Powdery mildew is a fungus that infects dry leaves in humid air. Downy mildew is a water mold that needs hours of wet leaves. Sprays sold to gardeners do little against it, so the useful tools are resistant varieties, timing and keeping leaves dry.

What it is

The downy mildews are oomycetes, or water molds, relatives of the organism that causes late blight and not true fungi. That matters in practice: many fungicides that work on fungi do not work on them.

Each kind infects one plant family or even one genus. The downy mildew on cucumbers cannot infect basil, and the one on impatiens cannot infect coleus or anything else in the bed. All of them are obligate parasites that grow only in living tissue. They produce spores on the underside of the leaf at night, the spores travel on wind, and they infect when leaves stay wet from dew, rain, fog or sprinklers. Six to twelve hours of leaf wetness is ideal for the cucumber mildew, and four hours or more favors the one on impatiens. New spores can appear as soon as four days after infection.

Symptoms

  • Top of the leaf: pale green to yellow patches, often with straight edges where veins stop them, starting on older leaves. On cucumber the effect is a patchwork. On melons, squash and many other plants the patches are less regular.
  • Underside: a downy growth right under each patch, gray to dark purple on cucurbits, basil, spinach and brassicas, white on lettuce, grape and impatiens. Look early in the morning, when the night's spores are fresh.
  • Later: patches turn brown, leaves curl and die, and fruit is left exposed to sunscald. The fruit of cucurbits is not infected, but it is fewer, misshapen and poorer in flavor.

Downy mildew, powdery mildew or a nutrient problem

Downy mildew Powdery mildew Nutrient deficiency
Cause Water mold Fungus Shortage or lock-up of a nutrient
Top of leaf Yellow, often angular patches bounded by veins White powder that rubs off Even yellowing in a regular pattern: whole older leaves (nitrogen), leaf edges (potassium), between green veins (magnesium)
Underside Gray, purple or white fuzz under each patch on damp mornings White powder, or nothing Nothing
Weather Cool to mild nights, wet leaves, humidity above about 85 percent Humid air, dry leaves, shade, 68 to 80°F Not weather-driven
Course Can strip a planting in a week or two Builds over weeks and rarely kills the plant Slow, and much the same across the whole planting
Wet leaves Required for infection Not needed, and do not cause it Not involved

Basil with downy mildew is easily mistaken for a hungry plant. Turn a leaf over before you reach for fertilizer. Penn State Extension has a longer comparison of the two mildews.

The kinds a gardener meets

Cucumbers, melons and squash (Pseudoperonospora cubensis). Outdoors it survives winter only where cucurbits stay alive, in southern Florida and other frost-free places, and it blows north each summer. In North Carolina it typically starts in June; in the Northeast it usually arrives in mid-August or September and occasionally in July. Cucumbers and cantaloupes are susceptible to every strain, and cucumber is the crop gardeners most often lose; squash and pumpkins are susceptible only to some. The strains that attack cucumbers and cantaloupes are different from the ones on squash and watermelon, so a report on squash in your state does not mean your cucumbers are next. A strain that reached the US around 2004 overcame the resistance in the cucumber varieties of the time, so "DM" on an old variety means little. More in cucumber problems.

The national tracking site, cdm.ipmpipe.org, still takes outbreak reports and offers e-mail alerts when new outbreaks are confirmed, but its forecasting pages carry a notice that the risk forecasts stopped with the 2023 season for lack of funding. State extension vegetable newsletters are now the more reliable way to learn that it has reached you.

Basil (Peronospora belbahrii). The most damaging basil disease in the US. It arrives on wind, on transplants and on seed, and as far as is known it cannot survive without living basil, so it does not carry over in soil where winter kills the plants. It can infect at temperatures as low as 59°F and is worst in warm, humid late summer. See growing basil.

Spinach (Peronospora farinosa f. sp. spinaciae). A cool-weather problem, most active at about 59 to 70°F, and seen more often in the Northeast since winter growing in tunnels became popular. It exists as many races and new ones keep appearing, so no variety resists them all. It can form resting spores that survive in soil. See growing spinach.

Cabbage family (Hyaloperonospora brassicae). Worst on seedlings in cool, damp weather, where it can kill them. On older plants it causes yellow to orange angular spots; in broccoli, gray streaks under the beads running back to the stem; on cauliflower, dark spots on the curd; in radish and turnip roots, internal brown or black discoloration from the crown down. It carries over on brassica weeds, overwintered crops and crop debris.

Impatiens (Plasmopara obducens). Affects all common bedding impatiens (Impatiens walleriana) and balsam impatiens. Leaves yellow and curl down as if dry, white fuzz forms underneath, then leaves and flowers drop and leave bare stems. Unlike the kinds above, it forms resting spores in the dying stems that stay in the bed and can infect impatiens planted there in following years. New Guinea impatiens and SunPatiens are not affected.

Lettuce (Bremia lactucae). Light green to yellow angular spots with white fluffy growth underneath, on older leaves first, in cool, damp weather. It has many races and keeps producing new ones.

Grapes (Plasmopara viticola). Yellow spots on the leaf with white cottony growth beneath; young berries turn brown and soft and never ripen normally. It overwinters in fallen grape leaves. European wine grapes (vinifera) are much more susceptible than American types, with French hybrids in between, and most fruit infection happens from early bloom to three or four weeks after.

What helps

  • Resistant varieties. This is the main defense for most of these crops.
    • Cucumber: 'DMR 401' showed the most resistance in Cornell's trials, and 'Bristol' also did well there and at the University of Massachusetts. 'Brickyard' and the picklers 'Citadel' and 'Peacemaker' are other choices. 'Marketmore 76' showed little resistance.
    • Melon: 'Trifecta' and 'Edisto 47'.
    • Basil: the Prospera series, the Rutgers varieties 'Devotion', 'Obsession', 'Passion' and 'Thunderstruck', and 'Amazel', which is sold as plants. A new race that gets past the Prospera gene was found on Long Island, New York, in 2021 and 2022. Thai, lemon, lime, spice and red-leaved basils get far fewer symptoms than green sweet basil.
    • Impatiens: the Beacon and Imara XDR series of bedding impatiens, or New Guinea impatiens and SunPatiens.
    • Spinach and lettuce: buy recent varieties and check the downy mildew races listed in the catalog.
    • Brassicas: no resistant varieties were available when the University of Massachusetts last reviewed the disease.
  • Plant early. For cucumbers and other crops that get the disease from spores blowing in during summer, an early planting yields before it arrives. Late sowings are the ones most likely to be lost.
  • Keep leaves dry. Water at the soil with drip or soaker hose. If you must use a sprinkler, water in the morning of a sunny day so leaves dry fast, never in the evening.
  • Sun and air. Full sun, wide spacing, trellised cucumbers and weeding all shorten the hours leaves stay wet. For basil the target is humidity below 85 percent inside the plant canopy.
  • Move pots. Bring potted basil indoors on rainy days and humid nights.
  • Remove infected plants. Pull badly infected plants so they stop producing spores. Basil and impatiens will not recover. Bag impatiens, roots and all, and put them in the trash, not the compost, and plant something other than bedding impatiens there for at least the next season or two; the resting spores may last longer than that.
  • Rotate spinach and brassicas (three years for spinach, two for brassicas), control cabbage-family weeds, and rake up fallen grape leaves, since these kinds can carry over in soil or debris. Rotation does nothing against the kinds that blow in each year.

What does not help

  • Most home-garden fungicides. For basil and impatiens, extension pathologists say plainly that the products sold to home gardeners are not effective. For cucumbers, chlorothalonil and copper are the only products available to gardeners that do anything, they work only if applied before infection once the disease is reported in your area, and they are not enough once you can see it.
  • Copper as a cure. Copper is the organic option and it is weak against downy mildew, weaker than chlorothalonil on cucumbers. It is also a metal that builds up in soil with repeated use.
  • Fertilizer. The yellowing is not hunger.
  • Sprays for powdery mildew. The two diseases are caused by unrelated organisms, so check that a product's label names downy mildew on your crop before buying it.

Sources