Growing Butternut Squash in the Home Garden

Growing Butternut Squash in the Home Garden

Butternut squash (Cucurbita moschata) is a long-season winter squash with a tan, bell-shaped fruit and sweet, smooth orange flesh. It takes about 100 to 120 days from seed, so plant it as early as your frost dates allow. In return it is one of the best keepers among winter squash, and it is the squash to grow if squash vine borers ruin your zucchini: its solid, fibrous stems resist them.

'Waltham Butternut' is the standard full-size variety. Smaller types such as 'Honeynut' produce single-serving fruit, and compact or bush varieties suit smaller gardens.

Planting

When: butternut needs warmth. Sow after your last frost date, once the soil is at least 60°F; seeds come up fastest in soil between 70 and 85°F. Count back from your first fall frost to make sure the variety has time to ripen. In short-season areas, start seeds indoors in individual pots 3 to 4 weeks before transplanting and harden the seedlings off before planting out.

Where: full sun and fertile, well-drained soil with a pH of 6.0 to 6.8. Work in compost or well-rotted manure before planting. Loose, well-drained soil prevents waterlogging and root rot.

Spacing: sow seeds 1 inch deep, with plants about 3 feet apart in rows 6 feet apart, or two plants per hill with hills 4 to 6 feet apart. The vines run 10 feet or more.

Trellising: a strong trellis saves space and keeps fruit off the ground. Full-size butternuts weigh several pounds, so support the fruit with a cloth sling tied to the trellis.

Care

Water. Give plants about 1 inch of water a week, more in hot weather and while fruit is sizing up. Water at the base so the leaves stay dry, and mulch to hold moisture and keep weeds down.

Feeding. Mix compost into the bed at planting and side-dress once with compost or a balanced fertilizer when the vines begin to run. Avoid heavy nitrogen, which grows long vines at the expense of fruit.

Pollination. The first flowers are usually male. Female flowers, with a tiny squash at their base, follow a week or two later. If young fruit yellows and shrivels, pollination is failing; hand-pollinate in the morning.

Late season. About a month before your first expected frost, pinch off new flowers and small fruit that won't have time to ripen.

Pests and diseases

  • Squash vine borer: butternut is one of the most resistant squash, so borers are rarely a problem.
  • Squash bugs: butternut is among the less susceptible squash, but squash bugs still feed on it in some gardens. Check the undersides of leaves and destroy egg clusters.
  • Cucumber beetles: they chew seedlings. Cover young plants with row cover until the first female flowers open.
  • Powdery mildew: white patches on the leaves, usually from midsummer. It doesn't need wet leaves, so space plants for airflow and choose varieties labeled powdery mildew resistant (PM). Treat early with potassium bicarbonate, sulfur or horticultural oil if needed.
  • Blossom-end rot: a dark, sunken, leathery patch at the blossom end of fruit that had been growing normally. It comes from uneven watering, drought or root damage far more often than from low soil calcium. Keep soil moisture steady, and add calcium only if a soil test shows it is low. Small fruit that yellows and shrivels from the tip soon after flowering is a different problem: it wasn't pollinated, or the weather was too hot.

Harvesting

Butternut is ripe when the skin has turned a deep, even tan with no green streaks, the rind is hard enough that your thumbnail won't dent it, and the stem next to the fruit is dry and corky. The tan color arrives about two weeks before the fruit is fully mature, so if frost allows, leave it on the vine a couple of weeks after it colors up. Pick before a hard frost; frost damages the fruit and shortens its storage life, and so do repeated cold spells below 50°F.

Cut the squash from the vine with pruners or a sharp knife, leaving 1 to 2 inches of stem, and don't carry it by the stem.

Curing and storage

Cure butternut at about 80 to 85°F for 5 to 10 days, in a warm room or outdoors in a sunny, dry spot. Curing hardens the rind, heals small nicks and speeds the change of starch to sugar. It matters most for fruit with scrapes and for squash you want to keep all winter; sound butternut that will be eaten within a few months stores well without it. Then store the squash in a single layer at about 50 to 55°F in a dry place. Avoid storing it below 50°F, which causes chilling damage.

Butternut is not at its best straight off the vine. It gets sweeter and deeper orange over its first month or two in storage, so start eating it after that. It keeps two to three months and often up to six, which makes it one of the last winter squash to use up.

Butternut is good roasted, in soups and purees, and in place of pumpkin in pies and baking. For other types, see winter squash.

Sources