Herbicide Damage in the Garden: Drift and Contaminated Compost, Manure and Hay

When the new growth on tomatoes, beans, peppers or grapes comes out twisted, cupped, narrow and fern-like while the older leaves look normal, the usual cause is a hormone-type weed killer. It reaches a garden by two routes. One is through the air, from a lawn, field or roadside sprayed with 2,4-D, dicamba or triclopyr. The other is through the soil, in hay, straw, grass clippings, manure or compost that carries the long-lasting pasture herbicides aminopyralid, clopyralid or picloram.

The two routes look alike on the plant and call for different responses. Drift is a one-time dose that plants often outgrow. Contaminated mulch or compost keeps feeding herbicide to the roots, can last for years, and has to be found with a simple bean or pea test before it goes on the garden.

What the damage looks like

These herbicides imitate a plant growth hormone. They move to the growing points, so symptoms show on new growth, not on leaves that were full-sized at the time:

  • leaves cupped up or down, puckered, strap-shaped or fern-like, with crowded parallel veins
  • twisted, bent or thickened stems and leaf stalks, sometimes split, sometimes with roots breaking out along the stem
  • flowers that drop, and tomatoes that are misshapen, catfaced or elongated with a pointed tip
  • on grapes, small, deformed leaves with sharply toothed edges; redbud, maple and elm are among the most sensitive trees and show the same distorted new leaves
  • on beans and peas, stunted seedlings with curled, thickened growing tips; with soil residues, seeds that fail to come up

Tomatoes and grapes are the most sensitive plants in the garden. In Ohio State trials grapes showed symptoms at 1/800 of the field rate of 2,4-D or dicamba, and tomatoes and peppers at 1/300. Peppers, eggplant and beans are close behind. Grasses, including corn, are not affected, which is why these chemicals are used on lawns, pastures and grain.

Glyphosate (Roundup and similar) is a different kind of herbicide and looks different: new leaves turn yellow or white between the veins and come out small and distorted. It injures plants when spray lands on or drifts onto them, and it is not one of the herbicides behind compost and manure problems.

Telling it apart from look-alikes

Cause What separates it
Herbicide Several unrelated broadleaf plants show it at once, including weeds; only growth made after exposure is affected; distinct cupping and parallel veins
Virus Usually one kind of plant; light and dark green mosaic along with the distortion; no distinct cupping
Physiological leaf roll Older, lower tomato leaves roll upward and feel leathery in heat or after heavy pruning; veins and new growth are normal; harmless
Broad mites Bronzed or russeted undersides of young leaves and fruit; mostly on plants raised in a greenhouse or under shade; the mites are too small to see, so a lab has to confirm
Nutrient deficiency Yellowing in a regular pattern, usually on one crop, with normally shaped leaves

If you cannot tell, send photos or a sample to your extension office before deciding. See also tomato diseases and deformed tomatoes.

Route one: drift and vapor

Where it comes from. Lawn weed killers, including weed-and-feed products, pasture and roadside sprays, and corn, grain and cotton fields. The usual ingredients are 2,4-D, dicamba, MCPP and triclopyr, alone or mixed.

How it travels. Spray droplets ride the wind; Texas A&M notes that winds as low as 5 mph can carry them up to a mile. These chemicals also evaporate from treated ground and leaves and move as vapor, most of all in hot, dry weather, and ester formulations are more volatile than amine ones. On a still evening the vapor can hang in a layer of cool air and travel several miles overnight. So the neighbor who sprayed on a calm, warm day did not avoid the problem.

Timing. Symptoms appear from a day or two to a couple of weeks after the application. Minnesota's extension service documents tomato and pepper injury one to two weeks after a lawn treatment next door.

Will the plant recover? Often, from a light dose. If new shoots come out normal within a week or two and four to six weeks of season remain, the plant can outgrow it. In a Purdue case study, slicing tomatoes hit by 2,4-D at first bloom lost most of their first flower clusters, took about seven weeks to grow out of it, and cropped two to three weeks late; cherry and grape tomatoes beside them showed nothing. If new growth keeps coming out distorted, pull and replant if the calendar allows. Nothing you can spray or feed reverses the injury; water in dry spells and wait. Heavy doses can kill grapevines and leave trees weak for years.

What to do.

  • Photograph the damage with dates and note what was sprayed nearby and when.
  • Talk to the neighbor or applicator. Most cases are carelessness, not malice.
  • Your state department of agriculture investigates pesticide drift. Oregon and Illinois, for example, ask for complaints within 30 days of noticing damage.
  • On your own lawn, pull weeds or spot-treat them on a cool day with a light breeze blowing away from the beds, never in hot, dry, windy or dead-still weather.
  • Do not mulch or compost clippings from a lawn treated with these products within the past six weeks.

Route two: carryover in hay, straw, manure, compost and clippings

The chemicals. Aminopyralid, clopyralid and picloram, sold for pastures, hayfields, grain, roadsides and commercial turf under names such as Milestone, GrazonNext, Grazon P+D, Stinger and Confront. Clopyralid products have not been registered for home lawns since 2002, but golf courses and commercial turf still use them.

How they get to you. They stay active on the hay or straw; hay stored three years in a dry barn has still damaged crops. Animals that eat treated forage are unharmed and pass the herbicide in urine and manure for three to seven days afterward. Composting does not destroy it, and it breaks down especially slowly in piles of manure and compost. So it arrives in baled hay or straw mulch, horse and cattle manure, stable bedding, mushroom compost, bulk compost and "garden soil" blends, and clippings from treated turf. See hay versus straw, manure and composting.

Sensitive crops. Tomatoes, peppers, eggplant and potatoes; beans, peas and other legumes; lettuce, sunflowers, marigolds and dahlias; carrots and their relatives; squash and cucumbers; spinach, chard and beets; grapes, roses and strawberries. Corn, other grasses, lilies and irises show no injury.

How long it lasts. From a month or so in warm, moist, biologically active soil to several years. Oregon State gives two to five years for a contaminated bed to clear completely. The aminopyralid label bars hay or straw from fields treated in the previous 18 months from use as mulch or compost.

The bean or pea test

Run it on any new source before it touches a vegetable bed. It takes three to four weeks.

For compost, manure or soil mix:

  1. Take small scoops from many places, deep inside the pile as well as the surface (North Carolina State suggests 20), and mix them. Test each source separately.
  2. Fill three to six small pots with a half-and-half blend of the material and bagged potting mix. Some extension versions use two parts material to one of potting mix.
  3. Fill three more pots with potting mix alone as the comparison.
  4. Set each pot in its own saucer so water cannot run from one to another.
  5. Sow three pea or bean seeds per pot, water, and grow them in good light until they have three sets of true leaves, two to three weeks after they come up.
  6. If the comparison plants are normal and the test plants are stunted, cupped or curled, do not use the material on vegetables or flowers. If all are normal, it is probably safe.

For hay, straw or grass clippings: fill the pots with potting mix, sow the seeds, and lay a thick layer of the material on top so that every watering runs through it. Sample several bales. Compare with uncovered pots in the same way.

Tomato seedlings can be used in place of beans, but damage may not show until fruit sets five to seven weeks later, so beans and peas give a faster answer. Laboratory tests cost a few hundred dollars per chemical and can miss levels that still damage plants.

What to ask a supplier

  • For hay or straw: what was sprayed on the field, and when? Is it certified organic? Clover or alfalfa in the bale suggests no broadleaf herbicide was used, though its absence proves nothing.
  • For manure: what were the animals fed, where did the hay come from, and what was sprayed on that hay or pasture? Healthy animals tell you nothing.
  • For bulk compost or soil: does the maker run plant bioassays on each batch, and can you have a sample of the batch you would be buying?

Recovering a contaminated bed

  1. Rake off and remove any contaminated mulch.
  2. Till or dig the soil several times through the season and keep it watered. Soil microbes break the herbicide down, and they work fastest in warm, moist, aerated soil. Clean compost or leaves help feed them.
  3. Grow something that is not affected: sweet corn, or a grass-family cover crop such as oats, annual rye or sudangrass. Do not put the residue from these crops on other beds or into compost meant for vegetables.
  4. Repeat the bean test in that soil once or twice a year. When test plants grow normally, broadleaf crops can go back.
  5. Use leftover contaminated compost on the lawn or around ornamental grasses, never on vegetable or flower beds, and tell the supplier.

Removing and replacing the soil works but is costly. Oregon State also lists activated charcoal, which binds these herbicides: 1 pound stirred into 1 gallon of water and sprinkled over 150 square feet. It can raise soil pH.

Is the produce safe to eat?

Extension services decline to say yes. Herbicide labels set legal residue limits only for the crops the product is meant for, and nobody knows the dose a drifted garden received. Oregon State, Iowa State, Virginia Tech and Illinois all advise against eating produce from plants that show injury when the herbicide is unknown. Illinois adds that plants with no symptoms by harvest are likely fine. If you know exactly which product was involved, the National Pesticide Information Center (800-858-7378) will talk through the risk for that chemical.

Sources