Epsom Salt, Eggshells, Coffee Grounds and Other Garden Amendment Myths

Most garden folklore about amendments starts from a true fact and stretches it. Magnesium really is part of chlorophyll, phosphorus really is needed for roots, and gypsum really does fix one kind of bad soil. The stretch is the idea that if a nutrient cures a shortage, more of it will boost a plant that already has enough. It doesn't. A plant that was short of something resumes normal growth when the shortage is corrected; a plant that was not short does nothing, or does worse.

So the answer to nearly every item below is the same: a soil test tells you whether there is a shortage, and where there is none, the amendment is wasted or harmful.

Amendment Popular claim What the evidence says
Epsom salt Greener leaves, more blooms, no blossom end rot Helps only a tested magnesium shortage
Eggshells Prevent blossom end rot No; compost them
Coffee grounds Acidify soil, fertilize, repel slugs Not reliably acidic; fresh grounds stunt plants
Banana peels A potassium boost Too slow; compost them
Bone meal, bloom boosters More roots and flowers Only where phosphorus tests low; harmful elsewhere
Rock dust Remineralizes soil No effect in a three-year trial
Compost tea Prevents disease Not shown in field trials
Mycorrhizal inoculants Better roots No gain in garden soil
Biochar Permanent soil improvement Depends on the soil; can backfire
Vitamin B1 Prevents transplant shock No
Gypsum Loosens clay Only in high-sodium soil
Sand in clay Improves drainage Makes it denser
Gravel in pots Improves drainage Keeps the potting mix wetter

Epsom salt

The claim: a spoonful makes tomatoes and peppers greener, bushier and more productive, and prevents blossom end rot.

The true part: Epsom salt is magnesium sulfate, and magnesium is needed to make chlorophyll. Plants that are short of it turn yellow between the veins, oldest leaves first. Researchers identified magnesium deficiency in commercial orchards in the 1930s and treated it with magnesium sulfate, with mixed success. Deficiency is most common on sandy, acidic soils.

What trials found: every study that showed a benefit was on an intensively farmed crop that was magnesium-deficient to begin with. Washington State University's review found no research on Epsom salt in home gardens at all, and garden soils are rarely short of magnesium. Extra magnesium does not increase growth, leaves, flowers or chlorophyll. Too much competes with calcium and potassium for uptake, so it can make blossom end rot worse; it is a salt and can burn; and sprays scorch leaves. It has no effect on soil pH and none on pests.

Do instead: test. If magnesium is low and the soil is acidic, dolomitic lime fixes both; see soil pH. If magnesium is low and the pH is fine, use Epsom salt at the rate on the report.

Eggshells

The claim: crushed shells in the planting hole supply calcium and prevent blossom end rot.

The true part: shells contain calcium, and blossom end rot is a shortage of calcium in the fruit.

What trials found: the shortage is in the fruit, not the soil. Most soils hold plenty of calcium; the plant fails to move enough of it into fast-growing fruit when its water supply is uneven. Shells also break down very slowly. They do no harm.

Do instead: water evenly, mulch, and avoid cutting roots by cultivating close to the plant. Put the shells in the compost. See blossom end rot.

Coffee grounds

The claim: grounds acidify soil for blueberries, feed plants, and repel slugs and cats.

The true part: used grounds are more than 10 percent protein by weight, so they hold nitrogen, plus some potassium, phosphorus and magnesium. They make a good compost ingredient.

What trials found: the pH of decomposing grounds has measured from mildly acidic to somewhat alkaline and does not stay put, and it affects only the soil right around the grounds. Fresh grounds are toxic to plants: several experiments found poorer seed germination and stunted growth where they were dug in or used as mulch. There is no published evidence that they repel or kill any garden pest. Disease suppression has been shown only under controlled conditions on a handful of crops. A thick layer packs down and blocks water and air.

Do instead: compost them, at no more than 20 percent of the pile by volume. Keep them out of seedbeds and worm bins. To lower pH, use sulfur; see soil pH.

Banana peels

The claim: a peel buried beside a plant gives it a potassium boost as it rots.

The true part: banana peels contain potassium.

What extension says: peels buried in soil decompose slowly, their nutrients are not available to plants until they do, and meanwhile they attract pests and grow mold. Potassium is worth adding only where a soil test shows it is low.

Do instead: compost them with everything else.

Bone meal and "bloom booster" phosphorus

The claim: phosphorus builds roots and flowers, so put bone meal in every planting hole and feed flowering plants a high-phosphorus fertilizer.

The true part: phosphorus is essential; plants use it in DNA, cell membranes and energy transfer. Heavily cropped farm fields and some acidic, sandy soils are short of it, and crops there respond when it is added.

What research found: garden and landscape soils are rarely short of phosphorus. Where there is enough, adding more does not stimulate anything. The slogan "nitrogen for shoots, phosphorus for roots" arose because adding nitrogen to a hungry landscape gives visible top growth and adding phosphorus usually gives no visible response at all. Surplus phosphorus does harm: it stops roots from forming their partnership with mycorrhizal fungi, so a new transplant is less able to take up water; it competes with iron and manganese, causing yellowing between the veins; and it washes into lakes and streams, where it feeds algal blooms.

Do instead: add phosphorus only when a soil test shows it is low. At planting time, skip the phosphorus; steady watering and mulch are what a transplant needs.

Rock dust

The claim: powdered rock "remineralizes" tired soil and raises yields and the nutrient content of crops.

What a trial found: in a three-year outdoor experiment on three soils, with wheat followed by forage crops, a commercial volcanic rock dust had no effect, good or bad, on plant growth, on the nutrient content of the plants, or on soil microbial activity. The authors concluded the product was probably inert. That is one product in one study, and it does not prove that no rock dust ever helps. But a benefit has to be shown, and this careful test did not show one.

Do instead: if you suspect a trace-element shortage, have the soil tested for it.

Compost tea

The claim: compost steeped in water and sprayed on leaves prevents and cures plant diseases.

The true part: compost is good for soil, and compost steeped in water has long been used as a weak liquid fertilizer.

What research found: when Linda Chalker-Scott of Washington State University reviewed the question, there were only a handful of peer-reviewed papers, and the one field test she found reported no difference in disease control between compost tea and plain water. Batches differ so much in ingredients and microbes that one result says little about the next. Used heavily, tea delivers a dose of soluble nutrients that can leach away.

Do instead: spread the compost itself as a thin top dressing or mulch.

Mycorrhizal inoculants

The claim: packaged fungi added at planting give plants a better root system.

The true part: mycorrhizal fungi are real and valuable. They extend the reach of roots, especially for phosphorus and water. Inoculants can help in sterile potting media.

What trials found: healthy soil already holds these fungi. In landscape studies, inoculated plants performed no better than untreated ones, which were soon colonized by the fungi already in the soil. One study of several commercial products on four kinds of trees and shrubs found no improvement in growth or survival over plain bark mulch. And where soil is too rich in phosphorus, added spores simply stay dormant.

Do instead: stop adding phosphorus the soil does not need, keep a coarse organic mulch on the surface, dig less, and don't overwater or overfertilize.

Biochar

The claim: charcoal dug into soil improves it permanently, holding water and nutrients and feeding soil life.

The true part: biochar, made by heating plant material to a very high temperature with no oxygen, lasts for centuries in soil. It holds nutrients, binds heavy metals, raises pH, and improves water holding in sandy soil. Crops have grown better with it, and it suits sandy, acidic soils that are poor in organic matter best.

What research found: Washington State University's review found only a handful of studies relevant to home gardens. Biochar is least effective in soil already rich in organic matter, where too much can reduce growth and tie up nitrogen for a time. Because it raises alkalinity, it can injure acid-loving plants, and earthworm numbers often fall. It can waterlog heavy clay, and it makes soil-applied pesticides less effective. Products differ with what was burned and how. Charcoal made at home from yard waste is not the same thing, because the temperature is too low and oxygen is present.

Do instead: in a garden that already gets compost and mulch, skip it. If you want to try it, buy a commercial product with stated properties, treat a small area, and watch for pale, nitrogen-hungry plants.

Vitamin B1 for transplant shock

The claim: a vitamin B1 (thiamine) solution at planting stimulates roots and prevents transplant shock.

The true part: thiamine is a standard ingredient in the lab media used to grow plant tissue in culture. A 1949 study found better rooting from a commercial product that contained both thiamine and a rooting hormone (an auxin).

What research found: later work pointed to the hormone. Thiamine applied to the roots of whole plants does not stimulate root growth; in one study plain water did better. Plants make their own thiamine, and so do soil microbes.

Do instead: water new transplants often and mulch them. If anything is added, a little nitrogen is enough; skip "transplant fertilizers" that are high in phosphate.

Gypsum for clay

The claim: gypsum loosens clay, improves drainage and breaks up compaction.

The true part: gypsum (calcium sulfate) does improve sodic soils, where sodium has collapsed the structure, by replacing the sodium with calcium. Such soils occur mainly in arid and coastal regions. It can also help some heavily weathered or intensively farmed clay soils.

What research found: on other soils it has no effect on structure, fertility or pH. Its effects last only months, and it can leach iron and manganese, bring on magnesium deficiency in acidic soil, and set back mycorrhizal fungi.

Do instead: improve clay with organic matter and mulch, and stay off it when it is wet; see clay. Use gypsum only where a soil test shows high sodium, or low calcium in a soil whose pH you do not want to raise.

Sand in clay

The claim: mixing sand into clay makes it drain like loam.

What soil physics says: clay has only tiny pores and sand only large ones. Mix a modest amount of sand into clay and the clay particles fill the large pores, leaving a soil denser than either one. It is the recipe for concrete. Sand has to make up about half the total soil volume before the mix starts to behave like sandy soil, which is out of reach for a garden.

Do instead: organic matter and mulch. See building healthy soil.

Gravel in the bottom of pots

The claim: a layer of gravel, pebbles or broken pots under the potting mix improves drainage.

What soil physics says: water does not move readily from a fine-textured layer into a coarse one. It stays in the potting mix until the mix is saturated, and only then drips into the gravel. Soil scientists showed this about a century ago, and one study found that the coarser the layer underneath, the more water stayed in the soil above. A gravel layer therefore leaves the roots with less depth of mix and a wetter bottom, the opposite of what was intended.

Do instead: use a pot with drainage holes and fill it with the same mix from top to bottom. See container gardening.

Sources