Tomatoes › Varieties

Brandywine Tomatoes: Strains and How to Grow Them

Growth habit
Indeterminate
Heirloom or hybrid
Heirloom
Color
Red

Brandywine is the heirloom many gardeners measure other tomatoes against: a big, pink beefsteak, often a pound or more, with an intensely rich, sweet-tart flavor. It is also slow to ripen, a light producer, and fussy about heat. Grow it for flavor, give it your best spot, and grow a dependable hybrid alongside it if you need a reliable crop.

What to expect from the classic pink Brandywine:

  • Habit: indeterminate, with tall, sprawling vines.
  • Leaves: potato-leaf foliage, broad and smooth-edged instead of the usual serrated tomato leaf.
  • Fruit: large, slightly flattened and often lobed or ribbed, pink-red with pink flesh.
  • Maturity: late, often 80–100 days from transplanting to the first ripe fruit.
  • Weak points: fewer fruit per plant than most hybrids, poor fruit set in hot weather, a tendency to crack and catface, and no bred-in disease resistance.

Brandywine strains

Several different tomatoes are sold as Brandywine, and they are not just color versions of one variety.

Strain Fruit Notes
Pink Brandywine (often Sudduth's strain) Large, pink, flattened The classic; potato leaf
Red Brandywine Red The name covers several different red tomatoes, some with regular leaves; size and flavor vary by seed source
Yellow Brandywine Large, golden yellow to orange Potato leaf
Black Brandywine Dusky purple-brown Rich, earthy flavor like other "black" tomatoes

If you want the Brandywine people rave about, buy seed of the pink, potato-leaf type from a seller who names the strain.

Growing Brandywine

  1. Start seeds indoors 6–8 weeks before your last frost date, and transplant after it once nights stay above 50°F. Plant deeply, burying two-thirds of the stem.
  2. Full sun. At least 8 hours of direct sun if you can manage it; Brandywine needs every advantage.
  3. Space plants 2–3 feet apart, 3 feet if caged, so air moves through the dense foliage and leaves dry quickly after rain.
  4. Support from day one. Use 6–8 foot stakes or a strong cage at least 5 feet tall; the heavy fruit and long vines will flatten a small cone cage. See supporting tomato plants.
  5. Prune moderately. Removing suckers keeps the plant manageable and gives larger fruit. On a stake, keep one or two main stems. Once plants are 2–3 feet tall, remove the lowest leaves, which are the first to get early blight.
  6. Plant early in hot climates. Brandywine is notorious for dropping its flowers when days run above about 90°F or nights stay above about 75°F. In the South, transplant as soon as frost danger has passed so fruit sets before the summer heat, and use shade cloth during heat waves.

Soil

Brandywine does best in rich, loose, well-drained soil with plenty of organic matter, at pH 6.2–6.8. Work 2–3 inches of compost into the bed before planting, and don't plant where tomatoes, potatoes, peppers or eggplant grew in the past three years.

Watering

  • Water deeply, about 1–1.5 inches a week including rain, so the soil is moist 6–8 inches down. One or two thorough soakings beat daily sprinkling.
  • Keep moisture even. The big fruit cracks badly when heavy rain or watering follows a dry spell, and uneven watering also causes blossom end rot. A 2–3 inch mulch of straw or shredded leaves helps a lot.
  • Water at the base of the plant, not over the leaves. Wet foliage spreads early blight and septoria leaf spot.

Fertilizing

  • At planting, mix compost or a balanced fertilizer into the soil.
  • Once fruit sets, side-dress with a balanced or tomato fertilizer, or a ring of compost, every 3–4 weeks.
  • Go easy on nitrogen. Brandywine already grows plenty of leaves; extra nitrogen makes it leafier and slower to fruit.

Pests, diseases and harvest

Hornworms, aphids and stink bugs are the usual pests; hand-pick hornworms and knock aphids off with a spray of water. Brandywine has no bred-in disease resistance and its long season gives early blight and septoria plenty of time to build up, so rotation, mulch and dry leaves matter more than usual (common tomato diseases). If a soil-borne wilt is the problem, see grafted tomatoes.

Pick when the fruit is fully pink and gives slightly when squeezed, or pick at the first blush of color before heavy rain and let it ripen on the counter. That saves many big fruits from cracking (when to pick tomatoes).